Sunday, November 22, 2026
Sumanta Sen
- It might be a few centuries late but Britain is at last considering steps to outlaw trade in stolen antiquities.
The British Museums are full of treasures brought to the United Kingdom from its former colonies and other parts of the world. But Britain has refused so far to join 91 other countries in signing up to a United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO) convention to outlaw such business.
That might change now. “We are studying the recommendations of a committee which advised us on this matter and we will set out a course of action shortly,” a spokesperson for the department of culture, media and sports told IPS in London this week.
Successive British governments have refused to sign the convention since it was published by Unesco on Nov 14, 1970. Officials have cited legalistic reasons. But minister for culture, media and sports, Alan Howarth, now says the decisions against signing were not founded in legal arguments.
The Illicit Trade Advisory Panel, which was asked to advise the British government, has recommended that Britain sign the Unesco convention. It has also recommended the creation of “a new criminal offence of importing, dealing in or possessing stolen or illegally excavated cultural objects”. The recommendations, made on Dec 18, will be taken up now after the Christmas break, the spokesperson said.
The advisory panel was headed by Norman Palmer, barrister and Professor of Commercial Law at University College London. “Since the licit UK market in cultural objects is the second largest in the world, accounting for 30 per cent of the global art market, it is particularly important to ensure that its integrity is maintained,” Palmer said.
Commenting on its recommendations, Howarth said he had set up the advisory panel because “we have received disturbing reports of cultural depredation both within and beyond the United Kingdom.” But Howarth has still not accepted the recommendations. He said “I note the panel’s recommendation that we should accede to the Unesco Convention and their view that we can do so without the need for any further legislation.”
The panel advised the ministry, however, against adopting a follow-up agreement in Rome in 1995 that would bind signatories to adoption of a minimal code as law.
Moves to adopt the recommendations of the advisory panel are certain to face strong resistance from the trade and from supportive sections of government. According to trade estimates, the business in stolen antiquities is worth about a billion dollars a year in Britain. The business in insuring objects alone is estimated to be worth a few hundred million dollars.
The law will not cover ongoing disputes such as the Elgin marbles from Greece kept in the British Museum. Or Indian claims to the Kohinoor diamond lodged in the Queen Mother’s crown. But adoption of the recommendations could arm the British police against a continuing trade in stolen antiquities.
Some success has come the way of claimants already. In one case a 12th century figure of the Hindu god Nataraja which had been bought by a Canadian company was returned to India after a historic case in which the Shiva Lingam, a phallic symbol of creative power, was made the plaintiff.
In 1995 three truckloads of Chinese artifacts were seized a day before they were due to be auctioned, and most of them were returned to China. A collection of Roman silver due to be auctioned was saved just in time after the export licence for the silver was declared invalid. Such successes are scarce, however, in the face of the massive trade in stolen artifacts through London every year.
Under the Unesco convention “states which are party to the Convention are bound to return to other State Parties cultural property that has been stolen from a museum or similar institution and is inventoried, to take measures to control the acquisition of illicitly traded cultural objects by persons and institutions in their country, to co-operate with other States having severe problems of protection of their heritage by applying import controls based on the export controls of other States Parties, and to take steps to educate the public.”
To many in the trade, this convention can mean the death of their business.
To strengthen the convention Unesco asked the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT) to draw up a new treaty to complement the 1970 convention by providing minimal rules of uniform law. This resulted in the UNIDROIT Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural Objects agreed in Rome in 1995. But the Palmer panel has advised the British government against adopting this agreement that would nail governments down to specific action.
Unesco celebrated 30 years of adoption of the convention in Paris in November last year. But with major players like UK and the US refusing to come on board, governments of countries losing their treasures to antique hunters believe there is little yet to celebrate.