Development & Aid, Education, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, North America

POLITICS: Middle East, Muslim Students Shun U.S. Schools

Miriam Kagan

WASHINGTON, Nov 3 2003 (IPS) - For many years, students from all over the globe have streamed into U.S. universities in search of a good education, career opportunities and, at times, freedoms not available at home, thanks to a relatively open and streamlined student visa process.

That easy access is no more, especially for students from Muslim countries and the Middle East, concludes a report released Monday by the Institute of International Education, a non-profit international education forum.

‘Open Doors 2003’, the IIE’s annual report on international education, finds that after five years of steady growth, the number of international students attending colleges and universities in the United States increased only slightly from the previous year, up less than one percent from 2001/2002.

Growth rates ranged from 2.0 percent to 6.4 percent between 1997 and 2002.

Of the top 20 sending countries, 13 saw decreased numbers of students travel to U.S. schools. In particular, enrolment of students from Indonesia was down 10 percent from the previous year, Malaysia 11 percent, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait 25 percent, and students travelling from the United Arab Emirates declined 15 percent.

All are Muslim-majority nations.


The total number of students coming from all countries in the Middle East was 34, 803, down from 38, 545 the previous year.

Not all nations sent fewer students. For the second consecutive year, India was the leading country of origin for international students going to the United States, sending 74,603 students, 12 percent more than last year.

Increases were also noted in students from South Korea (up 5 percent to 51,519) and Kenya (up 11 percent to 7, 862).

Despite the slowdown in foreign student enrolment, ”America is a welcoming nation and keeping our doors open to men and women of goodwill from every part of the globe is vital to mutual understanding and to our own well-being”, said a statement by Patricia Harrison, assistant secretary of state for educational and cultural affairs.

According to IIE President and CEO Allen E. Goodman, the huge drop in the number of students from Muslim countries and the Middle East ”reflect(s) the impact of a number of factors: a weakened economic situation affecting many countries, student and family concerns about safety and an increased competition from other host countries”.

That explanation is challenged by Rabiah Ahmed, communications director at the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR). She says the real reason for the change is the policies Washington has adopted since the terrorist attacks of Sep. 11, 2001, which have either intimidated or effectively prevented students from applying to U.S. institutions.

“Muslim students don’t feel welcome and don’t feel safe in the U.S.,” Ahmed told IPS.

While new cumbersome regulations on student visa registration apply to every one, the “special registration” procedures that many Muslim males from designated countries were forced to undergo after 9/11 made Muslim students feel targeted and singled out.

“Even though special registration has now stopped, there are new policies that contribute to the perception that Muslims are being targeted,” said Ahmed.

For example, the Department of Homeland Security announced Monday that a new high-tech system will track over 24 million internationals entering the United States, including students.

The argument that competition from host countries might be preventing students from enrolling in U.S. universities is questionable, added Ahmed.

There is no official cap on the number of international students allowed to study in the country each year, so increased applications from one nation should not limit the seats available to students from another.

Also, despite the worldwide economic downturn, students are arriving in greater numbers from India, Mexico, Kenya, and China, countries whose gross domestic product (GDP) (and by implication students’ ability to pay) is lower than that of most Muslim and Middle East nations, she added.

According to Ahmed, the new rules and visa restrictions that are sending many college-bound youths from the Middle East to Canada, Europe or pushing them to decide to just stay at home, are also causing great frustration among Muslims already in the United States.

“While everyone wants to have an opportunity to study and make a good living, there is a lot of frustration. Many Muslims are being detained or deported, and for American Muslims it doesn’t seem safe here anymore.”

The decline in foreign students could also hurt U.S. universities. According to IIE, international students annually contribute more than 12 billion dollars to the U.S. economy.

Economics aside, many of those universities say they have a mission to provide a diverse and global environment for students to develop their ideas and examine their beliefs.

Restricting access to students from a whole part of the globe could result in just the kind of unilateral attitudes that many in the Middle East, Europe and Asia accuse Americans of having.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags