Asia-Pacific, Headlines, Human Rights

RELIGION-PAKISTAN: Cynicism Greets ‘Madrasah’ Reform Plan

Nadeem Iqbal

ISLAMABAD, Jun 27 2002 (IPS) - President Pervez Musharraf’s grand plan to ensure that Pakistan’s 8,000 religious schools would not be used to propagate extremism is being met with pessimism here.

Although many observers say it is a step in the right direction, they also say that the legal measures drawn up to see the plan through are rather weak and unlikely to help bring in the desired results.

But there are a few are still willing to wait and see what happens once the plan is put in effect, which officials say would be a week from now.

Shortly after the rules under a reform plan first announced earlier this year were announced last week, the English language daily ‘Dawn’ commented, “These regulatory rules have come at a time when serious efforts are being made to check the growth of militancy and sectarianism, which have often been linked to certain ‘madrasah’.”

“The latter,” it added, “could not be brought under scrutiny because of the absence of a governing mechanism and a competent authority to regulate and oversee the working of the ‘madrasah’ system. That deficiency has now been removed.”

On Jun. 20, the Cabinet gave the green light to a three-year programme to reform ‘madrasah’ or religious schools, which teach some 1.7 million students, some of whom are widely believed to have been part of the ‘jihadist’ network operating in Afghanistan and Indian-controlled Kashmir.

This means in part making the students take subjects other than those connected with religion.

In addition, the Cabinet approved a new law stipulating that anyone teaching militancy or sectarian hatred in the ‘madrasah’ could be punished with two years of rigorous punishment.

The ‘madrasah’ registration ordinance, however, actually seeks to have every religious school to be registered with an education board that would monitor, among other things, the schools’ sources of funding.

The new law also bars a religious school from admitting a foreign student or hiring a foreign teacher without first securing a no-objection certificate from the government.

Almost on reflex, the Muttahida Majlis-I-Amal, a coalition of around a dozen religious parties, rejected the new law, dubbing it as “foreign-sponsored”. It noted that the 25 million U.S. dollars for the programme to “reform” ‘madrasah; students would be coming mostly from the European Union and the United States.

The programme and the new ‘madrasah’ law are also seen as part of Pakistan’s efforts to comply with international pressure to support the U.N. Security Council Counter Terrorism Resolution 1373, which was passed several days after the Sep. 11 terrorist attacks in the United States.

The European Union in particular has been putting pressure on Islamabad to “undo” the ‘jihadist’ network believed to be based in the country, and which Delhi insists has been sponsoring violent activities in Indian-controlled Kashmir.

In a January 2002 report regarding its anti-terrorism efforts, Islamabad said it had already tightened the security on its long, porous borders as well as at its airports. It also said that the accounts of those it believes to be involved in terrorist activities had been frozen.

Islamabad reported that it was working on plans to curb money laundering and to bring religious schools in the mainstream of the education system.

Interestingly enough, although that report elicited sharp reactions from local fundamentalists, these were restricted only to biting media statements and failed to result in the usual street protests.

The recent announcement of the new law on the ‘madrasah’, meanwhile, has prompted another round of scathing remarks from religious leaders and groups.

Munawar Hassan, general secretary of the leading religious party Jamat-i-Islami, fumes that the decision to register schools was taken on the dictates of Washington.

In truth, many religious leaders are irked by the fact that the new laws restrict them from eliciting funds from foreign — mainly Muslim — countries or wealthy individuals.

Jamiat Ulmai Islam chief Maulana Fazalur Rehman wonders aloud why, if there is no restriction on secular nongovernment organisations getting aid from Western countries, then why should aid received by ‘madrasah’ from Muslim countries be restricted and put under strict government scrutiny?

Some observers, however, say that many students of Rehman’s schools somehow wound up as members of the Taliban.

In the meantime, how Islamabad plans to convince the ‘madrasah’ to register and therefore signal their willingness to be part of the change process remains to be seen.

Najum Mushtaq, an analyst working with International Crisis Group, told IPS that the most outstanding feature of the ‘madrasah’ ordinance is its prescriptive nature, rather than mandatory compliance, to introduce changes as smoothly as possible.

“The ordinance seeks voluntary registration,” says Mushtaq, who has just completed a study on the ‘madrasah’ system. “Changes in the curricula and new procedures of financial transparency will come into force after that.”

He adds that attempts by former military dictator Zia-ul-Haq to regulate the ‘madrasah’ system in early 80s failed because of stiff opposition from the clergy, “which was unwilling to compromise its autonomous financial and administrative status”.

Mushtaq also notes that Religious Affairs Minister Mehmood Ahmed Ghazi himself had described the new law that this law as “continuation of the process” started by Zia.

But, Mushtaq remarks, Ghazi failed to say how the clergy would be persuaded to comply by the law this time when a general with modernist leanings is ruling the roost.

Mushtaq explains that the main difference between Zia ul-Haq and Musharraf’s reforms is that the former wanted to make Pakistan a theocratic state, so while upgrading the standards of religious schools, he also wanted to introduce religious subjects in secular schools. Yet even then, Mushtaq says, the clergy resisted the government interference in the schools.

He says Musharraf may be up against even greater resistance, since he is doing things in reverse, and wants to introduce secular subjects in the religious schools.

Islamic University lecturer Aziz-ur-Rehman says among the law’s complications is the fact that education in a religious school lasts about eight years.

He says, “In this short duration, the students who mainly come from poor families barely become prolific in reading and writing. They are trained to lead rituals in mosques. The question remains, at what level should they be taught the new subjects and could they also understand them?”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags