Asia-Pacific, Headlines, Human Rights

PAKISTAN: Death by Stoning Sentence Spurs Outcry on Morality Laws

Nadeem Iqbal

ISLAMABAD, May 7 2002 (IPS) - Pakistan’s Gen Pervez Musharraf probably believes he now has the official mandate of the people after winning last week’s presidential referendum, but activists say he has to show that his commitment to anti-extremism goes beyond being but a campaign pledge.

Indeed, they say Musharraf can start by repealing the controversial Islamic laws — including the ‘Hudood’ Ordinance or morality laws – enacted by the dictator Zia ul-Haq during his rule from 1977 to 1988.

The activists say that for good measure, Musharraf can go further with the abolition of all laws that discriminate against women.

Such calls have become louder following the Apr. 17 sentencing of Zafran Bibi, a mother of five, to death by stoning in a public place.

Bibi, who had first approached authorities as a rape victim, not only saw the man she accused of violating her go scot-free, but has also found herself convicted of adultery.

Says a statement by the Alliance for the Repeal of Discriminatory Laws: “The recent verdict on Zafran Bibi is a shameful event for the entire nation. Punishing the victim herself, instead of delivering justice to her, was a disgrace to humanity.”

“Women’s rights are violated almost everyday,” the Alliance also says. “However, the government has failed to put an end mainly because these violations are very part of the constitutional structure of the country.”

Media reports say Bibi, whose husband has been in prison for two years now, had been repeatedly raped by her own brother-in-law. Finding herself pregnant, she told her mother-in-law of her ordeal.

Last March, Bibi’s father-in-law took her to the police station to register a rape complaint. But the father-in-law apparently told the police it was a member of a rival family who had violated Bibi.

It was only during the trial that Bibi was able to corrected that statement and pointed to her brother-in-law as her rapist.

The court then asked her to “prove” the rape. When she could not, the court, noting that she had been impregnated while her husband was behind bars, convicted her of adultery.

The 28-year-old Bibi has since given birth to a baby girl. But since Bibi has somehow become classified as a considered a “dangerous prisoner,” she has been locked up in solitary confinement in Kohat jail, some five hours away by car from here.

Her infant daughter, meanwhile, is being looked after by some female prisoners there.

Afrasiab Khattak, chair of the independent Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), confirms that “under the ‘hudood’ laws, the responsibility of proving a rape rests on the victim”.

While he says that death by stoning has yet been carried out in Pakistan, Khattak notes, “This is a typical case of abuse under the ‘hudood’ laws. These are the laws which are promoting extremism in society.”

Shariah, or Islamic, courts try cases falling under the ‘hudood’ ordinance. They operate in parallel with Pakistan’s ordinary criminal courts, which follow British laws.

Observers have said that despite his pronouncements against extremism, Musharraf is reluctant to undo the Islamic laws he inherited from the Zia ul-Haq administration, for fear of a severe backlash from religious groups.

But women activists determined to save Bibi have hired the services of some top lawyers and have challenged the decision on her case in the Shariah high court.

On May 2, around 50 rights activists also gathered outside Musharraf’s office demanding Bibi’s release and the abolition of the ‘hudood’ laws. They were beaten with batons and then dragged by the police.

Says Shahla Zia of non-government Aurat (Women) Foundation: “The incident has reminded us of the events of 1983, when the women activists demanding the repeal of discriminatory laws were beaten up in a similar way.”

Activists say that while Bibi has gotten the worst sentence so far, she is not the only victim of Pakistan’s “anti-women” laws. They point out that at present, 2,000 women are jailed in different parts of the country mainly because of these laws.

Activists also say that unwritten laws have made victims of other women as well, with hundreds losing their lives as a result of so-called “honour killings”.

These killings are usually carried out by a male member of a woman’s family and often claim not only the life of the woman herself, but that of the man who was supposedly having an illicit relationship with her.

Activists note that last year, Musharraf had proclaimed honour killing –

called ‘karo kari’ in the local language – as a crime. Data from the 2001 report of the HRCP, however, indicate that this kind of murder is on the rise.

.. In southern Sindh province, for example, 379 cases of ‘karo kari’ were reported in which victims included 226 women, 151 men and even two children. In Eastern Punjab province, the recorded number of murders carried out in the name of family honour last year reached 227.

Activists lament that those who do these “honour killings” are usually let off easy by the courts.

Although they insist that the President should make a firmer stand against such crimes, some women activists now believe that one of the main reasons for the rise in cases like this is also the limited female participation in the country’s executive, judicial and legislative bodies. This adds to a lack of sensitivity to and understanding of the social and cultural implications of discrminatory laws.

This is despite the fact that women constitute 48 percent of Pakistan’s 140 million population.

In 1997 election, only seven women wound up in the national assembly that had 210 men. In upper house, there were only two women compared to 85 men. These days, the federal bureaucracy has some 9,387 women, or a mere 5.7 percent of the total number of personnel and officials.

There is no woman judge in the Supreme Court or the Shariah high court while only five women have been appointed judges in the four provincial high courts.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags