Africa, Headlines

TECHNOLOGY-SOUTH AFRICA: Schools Becoming Battleground for Computer Firms

Jacqui Pile

JOHANNESBURG, Apr 11 2002 (IPS) - Schools in South Africa are becoming the battleground for computer companies.

At Mablomong farm school, west of Johannesburg, scores of primary school children attend class barefoot and begin most days with an empty belly.

But last month, their school received a computer room with 25 brand new machines – donated by a consortium of computer companies. Though they still have to walk kilometres to school, the children now have their own e-mail addresses and are learning the joys of computer games, like their more privileged counterparts in the city.

Mablomong is just one of 30 schools which will be used as part of a pilot study to enable the Gauteng government to assess who will best provide between R3bn (267.4 million U.S. dollars) and R5bn (445.7 million U.S. dollars) in information technology to schools over the next three years.

Guateng province comprises Johannesburg and Pretoria, the capital of South Africa.

The ambitious project, called Gauteng Online, aims to make computers available to every school child in the province, with the help of computer companies. Launched in January, the study involves six consortia of local computer companies that have donated hard- and software.

At stake is not just the lucrative public sector contracts, but the battle for market share, since children who use computer programmes at school are likely to use them in their jobs and studies later.

So far, it looks as if Microsoft has won support for its donation of free software to South Africa’s 32,000 schools, an initiative announced recently by President Thabo Mbeki, but competitors say the move may further entrench the company’s monopolistic hold on the market.

Most of the consortia have Microsoft software as part of their pilot solutions in the Gauteng Online project. But the Mecer and Sahara consortia have suggested Linux, an open-source operating system, whose code can be added to and enhanced by any user, as an alternative. Even alternative solutions usually use some Microsoft software, though.

Microsoft’s donation will cost it about R100 million (around 8.9 million U.S. dollars) a year in lost licence fees.

Competitors say the company is practising defensive marketing. “Microsoft knows it is under threat internationally as governments in Asia and Europe switch to cheaper, open source software,” says Tech-Knowledge Advantage Managing Director, Mark Turner.

Microsoft critics in the United States have accused the company of undercutting competitors there by flooding the market with free software.

A document by the National Advisory Council on Innovation (NACI) in South Africa advocates the use of open source software throughout government. The document says open source software has reached the critical mass that allows it to enter the mainstream software market.

NACI warns the Department of Arts, Culture, Science and Technology that the use of proprietary software, like Microsoft, where the core code is owned by the company which develops it, would make South Africa “dependent on foreign companies for much of our technological requirements and hostage to currency fluctuations”.

Many governments are now developing national policies to promote the use of open-source software. They include China, Thailand, Brazil, Argentina, Germany, France and Britain.

“It’s a Catch 22 situation,” says executive director of service provider Sangonet, David Barnard. “Looking forward, open source is probably the way to go, but Microsoft’s donation is sorely needed now to help bridge the digital divide.”

Turner reckons there is room for the two programmes to exist and one is unlikely to replace the other.

Microsoft’s director of customer satisfaction, Garry Hodgson, agrees. “We welcome Linux . . . (This project) allows government to pick the best systems.”

Linux was to be used in all five of the Mecer consortium’s schools. Now it is only in two, with Microsoft servers in the rest.

Turner says it will be much cheaper to establish Linux-run computer labs in South African schools, because “obsolete” Personal computers (PCs) can be used. He says it costs less than R1000 (89 U.S. dollars) per PC to set up. Microsoft-compatible PCs could cost up to R8000 (713 U.S. dollars) each.

But there is still concern about skill support for Linux.

“Unless you have the confidence to write code, where is the value?” asks Chief Executive Officer of Schoolnet South Africa, Rod Grewan.

Though open-source software may be more flexible, it is often packaged with a number of applications, which are not open source.

“This means it is very similar to proprietary software like Microsofts’,” says Grewan.

But long term, Linux may provide more room to grow. “Linux provides more flexibility for adapting to a developing country’s specific needs,” says Barnard. “Whereas Microsoft is developed in a first world nation, Linux can continually be enhanced to suit the user.”

As public sectors across the globe investigate switching to open source, developing countries such as South Africa should too.

Microsoft’s donation is generous, but government would do well to integrate it with other technologies that allow for a sustainable solution to the digital divide.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags