Africa, Headlines

BURUNDI-MEDIA: President Gets NGO Support for Banning ‘Hate Media’

Barbara Borst

PARIS, Jun 19 1995 (IPS) - Reporters Without Borders — an international non-governmental organisation which rallies to the cause of the rights of journalists — has however come out against Burundian Press, which it says, is fuelling the ethnic conflict.

As such, the Paris based organisation Monday welcomed the weekend announcement by Burundian President Sylvestre Ntibantunganya, who said he would ban all publications that sow ethnic hatred in the politically unstable central African nation.

In a nationally broadcast address on Sunday, Ntibantunganya declared that political radio speeches would be screened before broadcast and he called a special session of the national assembly to grant him power of decree through October.

He also announced measures to restore peace, including a nationwide curfew and prohibition of public demonstrations.

Publications “promoting ethnic hatred or apologising for violence” will be closed and the authors of such works pursued by the law, he said.

Herve Deguine of Reporters Without Borders (RSF) in Paris said his organisation is pleased to see the beginnings of action against newspapers and radio stations that have championed ethnic conflict and slaughter for 18 months or more.

Only last Friday, RSF published a report detailing the excesses of the print and broadcast media in Burundi, examining how the situation arose and advocating control over the extremist voices before they help foment greater violence.

RSF requested in April that Burundi’s president ban six such publications, three published by minority Tutsi extremists and three by Hutu, Deguine said, although they find that in general the Tutsi publications advocate more violence and are more widely distributed.

Ntibantunganya’s government is a power-sharing arrangement among the Frodebu (majority) and Uprona parties and includes members of both ethnic groups. Hutus make up 85 per cent of the population but Tutsis dominate the army and judiciary.

Frodebu (Burundi Democratic Front) won the country’s first elections in 1993 but President Melchior Ndadaye was soon killed during an attempted coup d’etat, and this triggered ethnic massacres. Uprona (Union for National Progress) was the only legal party under decades of dictatorship.

The RSF report reveals that the process of establishing democracy, which began after ethnic confrontations in 1989, opened the way for press freedom and for extremist tracts.

“As shocking or paradoxical as it may seem,” the report says, “the extremist papers with inflamed editorials were born in the demise of the single-party regime.” Before that, even indirect reference to ethnic conflict was forbidden.

The report reproduces a February article from “La Nation”, a Tutsi extremist bimonthly, arguing that the U.N. special representative, Ahmedou Ould Abdallah, and the U.S. ambassador, Robert Krugger, could be killed with impunity for taking sides in Burundi’s civil war.

It also presents a cartoon from “Le Temoin”, a Hutu extremist bimonthly, that depicts Tutsi leaders drinking Hutu blood through straws from a pot, as if it were traditional sorghum beer.

Deguine said RSF primarily defends press freedom worldwide and journalists who are imprisoned for their work. But in neighbouring Rwanda — the scene of ethnic massacres in 1994 — the group felt compelled to expand its role by denouncing the “media of hate” that played a major role in provoking genocide.

“In Burundi the media are contributing to a deterioration of the situation. They are directly responsible for crimes, as in Rwanda. Freedom of the press does not permit one to write just anything,” he said.

In Rwanda radio in the Kinyarwanda language spread the call among the Hutu majority for attacks on the Tutsi people and the Hutu political opposition, he continued.

Similarly, in Burundi half the 24 publications carry extremist messages, primarily in French but some also in Kirundi (the national language), that reach mainly urban elites sufficiently educated to read French. A quarter of all publications are party organs.

Radio, less potent in Burundi, is divided among the state broadcasting system, a Hutu extremist group, the Chamber of Commerce and Uprona.

“The first lesson we learned in Rwanda is that we acted too late. We should have campaigned against these media before the war. Fortified by the experience of failure in Rwanda, we are trying to be more effective in Burundi,” Deguine said.

The obstacles are many: The “hate media” are well financed by major political figures while state media are hamstrung by the power struggle between Frodebu and Uprona.

Well trained, objective journalists are hard to find in Burundi, Deguine added, because so many have been killed, gone into exile or become silent due to threats to their lives.

A well informed source from Burundi, who requested anonymity, described the media in his country as “mediocre” — nearly all aligned politically or ethnically and “very, very dangerous”.

The state-controlled radio and television are more neutral but ineffective in countering the propaganda of the others with unbiased information, said the Burundi source who has taken refuge in France.

“We must create a peaceful press that reaches the rural areas as well in the national language (Kirundi), one that preaches peace and educates toward democracy.”

Gregoire Birihanyuma, Frodeu representative in Paris, said the international media also must be more objective. He argued that events in Rwanda, where Hutu extremists are accused of genocide, have created a prejudice against Hutus in the foreign press.

The RSF report also calls on foreign journalists to avoid stereotypes and simplistic explanations of complex problems. It explains, for example, that ethnic conflict in both countries is not ancient enmity but modern, politically motivated rivalry.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags