Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

JAMAICA-MEDIA: Multi-million Dollar Libel Award Scares Journalist

Misha Lobban

KINGSTON, Jul 19 1996 (IPS) - A multi-million dollar award to a former politician in a libel case against the oldest newspaper in the island this week has raised concerns among media managers and journalists about implications for the future of the profession.

“The entire media fraternity should at this time be in sack cloth and ashes. This is a time of mourning for us in the media as many people will now be running to lawyers to sue the media for libel,” says Desmond Allen, Editor of the three-year old Jamaica Observer.

The 162-year Gleaner Company was this week ordered by a seven- member jury to pay a record 2.5 million dollars (80.7 million Jamaican dollars) award in damages for libel to Eric Anthony Abrahams, former Minister of Tourism in the Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) government in the 1980s.

This is the largest sum that any local medium has ever been ordered to pay in a libel suit and has left a chilling effect on the media fraternity.

Allen argues that such hefty sums in libel awards signal hard times for the local media as the level of aggressiveness that should be shown by local journalists will be compromised.

“Journalists will be more timid to report issues that have no … evidence even if the source is reliable,” he says.

The Press Association of Jamaica (PAJ) the umbrella organisation for journalists, supports the view.

“The PAJ is concerned that multi-million dollar awards will discourage journalists from being aggressive in their pursuit of information in the public interest,” says president, Jennifer Grant.

But Abrahams who is now a talk show host dismisses these concerns. “This is an extraordinary case about malice and persistence in a libel and should not be regarded as having a chilling effect on journalists or the journalistic expression,” he says.

The libel case arose out of an article published by the Associated Press (AP) news agency in 1987 and which was picked up by the Daily Gleaner and its afternoon tabloid, the Star.

The report was based on remarks by U.S. author, Robin Moore, that notes in his diary had sparked a federal investigation into allegations that Abrahams, while Minister of Tourism, had taken bribes from the American advertising firm, Young and Rubicam, in return for the island’s advertising and public relations contracts.

The articles were never retracted by the Gleaner and there was no apology, even after protests, says Abrahams who testified in court that the articles cost him his job as a tourism consultant and that his health was adversely affected as he went into a state of serious depression.

Meanwhile, popular radio talk show host, Wilmot Perkins also disputes the fact that the case against the Gleaner has implications for press freedom or journalism in Jamaica.

“This is a case in which the jury found the Gleaner did not act responsibly and persisted in its libel. Therefore, the local media shouldn’t feel threatened by it,” says Perkins. “… If we are responsible in our criticisms, then there should be no fear.”

Two years after the Gleaner ran the first stories, follow up articles were being published.

Hector Bernard, editor of the alternative newsletter, Insight, supports Perkins’ view. “It is only a danger to press freedom in so far as a jury feels that once libel is committed fantastic sums should be awarded but this award has nothing to do with press freedom or the threat of it,” he says.

A statement from the PAJ noted that the unprecedented award emphasises the awesome responsibility of local journalists and the need for members of the fraternity to understand what constitutes the legal framework of libel, slander and defamation of character.

“As journalists we have to continue to adhere to the ethics and standards of the profession that dictate the reporting of facts in an accurate and balanced manner,” the statement says.

The Gleaner Company is however appealing the award on the grounds that “it is manifestly excessive.”

“An award of this size must threaten the practice of independent journalism in Jamaica,” says the company’s Managing Director, Oliver Clarke.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags