Asia-Pacific, Headlines

CAMBODIA-MEDIA: Press Curbs Threaten Fledgling Democracy

Teena Gill

PHNOM PENH, Mar 12 1996 (IPS) - Cambodia’s excessively outspoken media have often been abusive in their attacks on the government, but Phnom Penh’s high-handed response does not augur well for the future of the country’s fledgling democracy, media analysts say.

The government has increasingly tightened its grip on publications whose critical comments it believes pose a threat to its authority.

The most recent case of intimidation against journalists was last month’s assassination attempt on radio announcer Ek Mongkok. He is known to be close to the royalist Funcinpec party which, though part of the ruling coalition, is still engaged in a power struggle with the Hun Sen-led Cambodian People’s Party (CPP).

Since late 1994, at least three print journalists who dared criticise the government are known to have been murdered. Many others have been jailed or fined, and a number of publications have been shut down.

“While the murder of Khmer journalists, like the editor of the ‘Samleng Yuvachon Khmer’ and another journalist at the ‘Khoh Santepheap’ daily is well known, what is not is that a number of other journalists have also been bumped off,” says a writer with one of the English-language papers in Phnom Penh.

After the United Nations-sponsored elections in mid-1993, Cambodia has seen a surge in the number of publications. There are now close to 50 Khmer publications, with an average daily circulation of 5,000 copies. Most of these are openly known to be pro-government, with only a few taking a critical stand.

The most popular, however, are the seven anti-government papers, including the ‘Samleng Yuvachon Khmer’ (Voice of Khmer Youth) whose circulation is estimated to be 5,000 to 6,000.

Several attacks on the premises of many of these papers and threats to target their production plants by CPP and Funcinpec supporters have prompted their regular printing houses to refuse to publish the papers, effectively silencing most of them.

“The government has no democratic experience and is not used to any criticism,” says former CPP member Phi Thach who is now director of the non-governmental Open Forum of Cambodia. “There is no political space to allow for civil society to develop.”

The passage of a new press law last year imposing stiff fines and imprisonment for reports deemed a threat to “national security” or “political stability” has been seen as an official attack on the freedom of the press.

“The use of criminal law against journalists and vague terms open to various interpretations like political stability is extremely dangerous,” says a senior official at the U.N. Human Rights Commission.

Of the five English-language papers, only two are openly critical of the government. One of them, the U.S.-owned Phnom Penh Post, has recently been taken to court for “disinformation, incitement and creating insecurity and instability”.

The case is still ongoing, but with the government dependent on large sums of foreign aid, including from the United States, most journalists in Phnom Penh feel it is likely that the publisher will be let off lightly.

It is, after all, not the English-language press, which is mainly read by the expatriate community, but the local publications which the government is most intolerant of.

With a literacy rate of more than 60 per cent nationwide and 80 per cent in Phnom Penh, the government is taking no risks.

The government’s paranoia also stems from the fact that Phnom Penh, where the majority of Cambodia’s intellectuals and political activists live, has a reputation for having always been the centre of revolt, and uncontrolled publications could lead to popular anti-government movements.

On the other hand, government sympathisers say reports of press freedom violations overlook the fact that while Western-style press institutions have been introduced in Cambodia since 1993, the rest of the country still operates in a context far removed from any semblance of normal society.

Not only has Cambodia had a democratic system of government in place for only two and a half years, the country is still struggling to battle the genocidal Khmer Rouge guerrilla group.

The economy also remains in a shambles, with the sudden rush of dollars due to massive U.N. presence and foreign investment only leading to more official corruption and a rapid rise in crime and organised prostitution.

Ngy Chanphal, Under-Secretary of the Ministry of Rural Development, says: “We must first rebuild our rural economy and create a situation of food security and employment which will take some time. We need this structure in place (before) we will be able to support democracy.”

Eighty per cent of Cambodians live in the countryside, and recent estimates show 1.5 million to six million people will enter the labour force by the turn of the century.

In addition to the 120,000 jobs that have to be created every year, the United Nations’ International Labour Organisation estimates an open unemployment backlog of 90,000 workers.

While the situation is far from normal, critics say it is more imperative at this time for the government to focus on addressing Cambodia’s economic problems and war with the Khmer Rouge than waste its energy in intimidating the press.

Historically, even during the relatively liberal 1960s, the Cambodian elite never had a great reputation for tolerating criticism.

With despotic French colonialism leaving behind virtually no democratic institutions, the country has since independence always operated in an atmosphere of authoritarian government control over most intellectual work.

The worst period was under the four-year rule of Khmer Rouge leader Pol Pot in the late 1970s during which intellectuals were hunted down to stop them from “corrupting” the rest of society.

Another factor now encouraging the government to maintain a hardline stance against the media is Cambodia’s growing economic and political integration into the fold of the Association of South-east Asian Nations (ASEAN).

With most ASEAN countries still running authoritarian regimes, there is little incentive for Cambodia to buck the trend and risk missing out on its dream of joining the club of economic tigers.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags