Sunday, November 22, 2026
Muddassir Rizvi
- When Pakistan opened a Friendship Gate along its border with Afghanistan this month, Afghan Defence Minister Gen Fahim was quick to denounce it, saying it sits on Afghan territory occupied by Pakistani troops after the fall of the Taliban two years ago.
When Pakistan opened a Friendship Gate along its border with Afghanistan this month, Afghan Defence Minister Gen Fahim was quick to denounce it, saying it sits on Afghan territory occupied by Pakistani troops after the fall of the Taliban two years ago.
Fahim’s remarks – and local authorities’ subsequent cancellation of the inauguration of a cross-border gate meant to encourage trade and other ties – underscores the tensions that plague ties between the neighbouring countries.
"This gate is part of our efforts to stop the illegal movement of people across the border," a spokesman for Pishin Scouts, a paramilitary force that mans the border area, told IPS by telephone, referring to the entry point near Chaman in Pakistan’s south-western province of Balochistan.
Countered an official from the Afghan foreign office: "Pakistan had not taken the Afghan administration in confidence before opening the gate. We will take up the issue with Islamabad soon.”
Relations between Pakistan and Afghanistan have been at an all-time low amid an ongoing war of words between the leaders and the officials of the two governments.
But the distrust of the Northern Alliance-dominated Afghan government in Islamabad is not new. It is rooted in Pakistan’s support of the Taliban – which the Northern Alliance had resisted – since the militia’s takeover of Kabul in 1996 and before that.
The Northern Alliance, which primarily comprises political groupings of non-Pashtun Afghans, holds Pakistan responsible for engineering the rise of the Pashtun Taliban through political, diplomatic, military and intelligence support.
Although Pakistan severed its relations with the Taliban students’ militia after the Sep. 11 attacks, as part of its newfound alliance with the U.S. government, the Northern Alliance leaders continue to view Islamabad with suspicion.
Historical animosity was also behind the attack and ransacking this summer of the Pakistan embassy in Kabul, in the wake of Afghan claims that Pakistani forces had taken over 30 kilometres of Afghanistan’s north-eastern territory.
Kabul now believes that its growing security woes are because of Pakistan’s laxness in combating remnants of al-Qaeda and the Taliban, who they say infiltrate Afghanistan and carry out attacks. It adds that these groups grew under the tutelage of Pakistan anyway.
But alarming for Pakistan is the fact that it is no less that Afghan President Hamid Karzai who has been issuing statements and giving interviews to foreign newspapers, indicting Islamabad of failure to curb terrorism. "We cannot stop this terrorism as long as Pakistan does not cooperate," Karzai told the German publication ‘Der Spiegel’ as reported by local newspapers on Nov. 23, 2003. "I think Pakistan can and should do more against terrorism."
Not surprisingly, the remarks irked the authorities in Islamabad. "What the Afghan leaders can and must do is to talk less and do more in putting their house in order," Masood Khan of the Pakistani Foreign office, said at a press briefing.
Khan said that Afghanistan could improve its security by curbing warlords, factional fighting and narcotics trafficking and production. "They (Afghanistan) have been advised by Pakistan, the United States and the UN Security Council (to do so)," added Khan.
The matter did not stop here. Kabul denounced Pakistan’s response as "irresponsible" and "undiplomatic". "Irresponsible remarks by a Pakistani spokesman cannot help us effectively address the real problems that feed terrorism and violent extremism," argued Omar Samad of the Afghan Foreign Office.
"To lecture another country about its internal challenges. . . falls outside diplomatic norms and the bounds of new friendly relations we hope to establish with the Pakistan government," Samad said.
Amid the war of words came Karzai’s statements to a British newspaper, ‘The Times’, in late November. He said that Taliban leader Mullah Omar was present in Quetta, capital of Balochistan province just across the Afghan border. He even identified the mosque where Omar was supposedly sighted.
"There is no truth in this report," said Information Minister Sheikh Rashid.
Pakistan has mobilised 70,000 troops to secure the Pakistan-Afghan border, but says that it needs technological help and training for surveillance of the 1,300-mile porous border between the two countries.
Authorities in Islamabad also refer to their crackdown against extremist Islamist groups and the freezing of their accounts, saying these are steps to combat terrorism.
Pakistan has thus far arrested more than 500 remnants of al-Qaeda and Taliban members and handed them over to U.S. authorities.
The suspicion of the Northern Alliance is such that officials in the Pakistani Foreign Office privately say they believe it takes its cues from rival India, in whose interest it is to restrict Pakistan-Afghan relations to a "functional level" and which had backed it against the Taliban.
A Dec. 2 meeting of the trilateral commission comprising Pakistan, United States and Afghanistan – which periodically discusses the efforts to go after al-Qaeda and Taliban – only tamed the hostile changes between Islamabad and Kabul a bit.
Omar Samad, Kabul’s spokesman said at the end of the meeting: "We have a problem with infiltrationàwith remnants of Taliban finding refuge and support.” He did not, however, name Pakistan as patron this time.
Meantime, Pakistani politicians argue that Islamabad’s interests lie in mending fences, not squabbling with Kabul.
"Deteriorating relations with our neighbour Afghanistan is not in the security interest of Pakistan," former Prime Minster Benazir Bhutto said in a press statement. "The stability of Afghanistan is important to the stability of Pakistan as well as of the wider world community."
"Islamabad should cool its obsession with the Northern Alliance and (President) Gen (Pervez) Musharraf should get on the phone to his friend Karzai and stop ungainly verbal jousting,” said the Lahore-based ‘Daily Times’ newspaper last week. But ”Mr Karzai would also do well to rein in his anti-Pakistan foreign office, dominated by stalwarts of the Northern Alliance.”
Muddassir Rizvi
- When Pakistan opened a Friendship Gate along its border with Afghanistan this month, Afghan Defence Minister Gen Fahim was quick to denounce it, saying it sits on Afghan territory occupied by Pakistani troops after the fall of the Taliban two years ago.
(more…)