Europe, Headlines

EDUCATION-MIDDLE EAST: Palestinian School Books Ignore Israel

Ben Lynfield

RAMALLAH, West Bank, Sep 7 2000 (IPS) - When 12-year-olds in Palestinian Authority (PA) schools begin their geography lessons this month, some of them may wonder about the green area on their maps that neatly surrounds the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

The area is known to the international community as the state of Israel, established in 1948.

But, seven years after the PLO recognised Israel, those devising the first-ever Palestinian textbooks have not followed suit, arguing that this will have to await Israeli recognition of Palestinian statehood.

PA leaders have said they intend to declare independence by the end of the year.

While past and present Arab cities are featured on the map, along with the PA governorates in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, sprawling Tel Aviv is nowhere to be found.

Israel captured the West Bank and Gaza Strip during the 1967 Middle East war, and the Palestinians hope to establish the independent state there.

“When they sign a final agreement, then our political institutions can decide to tell us what the [new] map is,” said PA Deputy Education Minister Naim Abu Hummus.

“We are in the first step of establishing our own curriculum. But if I ask an Israeli kid how he’s going to draw the map of Israel, he will draw it including our area too.”

As it stands, the PA map is drawn almost as if Zionism never happened, except that, in an accommodation to a painful reality, it includes a border between the West Bank and Gaza Strip and the green area.

In the Palestinian view, the way the map of British mandatory Palestine was transformed over the last century by Israeli sovereignty and expansion is, in a sense, what the conflict is all about.

For refugees, especially, the map of their collective memory includes locales that were built by Israel on the ruins of Arab towns and villages, then given Hebrew names.

And, since 1967, dozens of Jewish settlements have sprouted in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, many of them motivated by a desire to create a Greater Israel in the entire area of the former British mandate.

Mapping the current reality in the West Bank may be too confusing for peace negotiators, let alone pupils. Based on the 1993 Israeli-Palestinian self-rule agreement, Palestinian communities and land are divided into areas:A – under full PA control, B- partial PA control and C-continued Israeli occupation. Added to that are the settlements, which nearly break up the PA controlled areas into islands.

The maps and texts, which Palestinian educators have chosen, Palestinian analysts say, cannot be divorced from bitterness among the public that Israel has not concluded its occupation – or renounced its claims – in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

“Contrary to the official position of the PA, the public does not see the point of recognising Israel as a state while there isn’t a recognition of a Palestinian state,” says Ghassan Khatib, director of the Jerusalem Media and Communications Center.

The public’s attitude puts the Palestinian Authority, which has already recognised Israel, in a difficult position, he says.

“On the one hand, it gave recognition so it can’t say (Israel) is Palestine, but on the other hand it’s not easy to justify recognising Israel before you have a recognised (Palestinian) state.

That’s why there is a schizophrenic attitude in the PA. The map is a representation of schizophrenia on the part of the officials.”

Previously, the Palestinians used Jordanian and Egyptian textbooks, at times censored by Israel. But self-rule, launched in 1994, has now changed that.

On the Israeli side, maps and public discourse have also not come to terms with the process of Palestinian state-building. The army, for example, refers to the area around the Palestinian city of Ramallah as the Benjamin Area, named after a biblical figure.

Nor have newscasts ceased to refer to the West Bank and Gaza as Judea and Samaria, the biblical names favored by Jewish settlers.

Asked why a textbook chapter on tolerance shows a priest and a Moslem Sheikh shaking hands but has no rabbi, Abu Hummus said: “It is important to talk about tolerance when you put it in the right place and everybody gets his rights. When a peace solution is reached, the door will be open for many things,but it must be a just peace.”

“Without giving the Palestinians their rights, no newspapers or textbooks will change the situation,” Abu Hummus added.

“What will change the situation will be to have a final peace with Palestinian rights, not the building of (Jewish) settlements.”

Israeli government spokesperson, Moshe Fogel, says the maps are part of a broader PA problem in its attitude towards peace with Israel.

“We often hear the PA speaking in two voices, one for its own people and another for foreign consumption,” Fogel said.

“Whether it is from the education system or Arafat himself, there has to be a clear message of peace and long-term accommodation with Israel.”

“The problem is not just one of maps, it’s one of attitudes and concepts,” he added. “This change in attitude and concepts has yet to take place.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags