Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

BOOKS-INDIA: Just Who Gained from Independence?

R. Devraj

NEW DELHI, Aug 19 1997 (IPS) - India has been busy this month taking stock of 50 years of Independence and one of the best reports from the auditors has been the book by journalist P. Sainath; “Everybody Loves a Good Drought”.

Like the title itself, the book speaks of the stark and often ludicrous ironies that have become the hallmark of India’s impossibly skewed development process where India’s poor are usually reduced to agreeably abstract statistics.

Sainath’s book, which bagged the European Commission’s latest award for Journalism, gets right down to the nuts and bolts of rural poverty. Using simple narrative, peppered with paradoxical examples of poverty amidst plenty, Sainath’s stories demystify the causes and unerringly lays blame on exploitation with the collusion of a corrupt or indifferent officialdom.

The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) printed excerpts from one of his 68 stories in a document presented at the India Development Forum, held in Paris in June, to illustrate how vested interests systematically hijack development.

“Nahakul Pando took a loan of Rs 4,800 to buy two cows (a favourite anti-poverty asset). He could not repay it and was under pressure to pay back installments that had fallen due. He sold whatever he owned that had any value, including the cows. Finally, he was forced to sell his last remaining asset – tiles from his roof.

“Nahakul and the others needed money all right, but they couldn’t get it for the things they wanted. They had to take it for schemes that had no relevance to their needs. Normally, you take a loan to save the roof over your head. Nahakul took a loan to lose the roof.”

Another chapter in the book, “Lenders, losers, crooks and credit”, closely examines the absence of rural credit and consequent exploitation of peasants by moneylenders and traders who have over time acquired their meagre land and reduced them to bondage.

Usury has also been killing off agriculture in some of India’s most productive areas such as Nuapada – Kalahandi in Orissa where Sainath’s warnings were to prove prophetic in the hundreds of starvation deaths in the area this year, despite record harvests.

Heavily indebted by interest rates ranging from 120 to 380 percent, the able-bodied men of Kalahandi migrate to other states where they fall prey to contractors looking for cheap labour and Sainath suspects even get put on steroids to improve their productivity. But their plight pales in comparison to the near- slavery Sainath encountered in the Ramnad district of southern Tamil Nadu where perpetual indebtedness means that all a worker really gets is leftovers from the last meal on the master’s table.

A Supreme Court appointed commission estimated last year that the number of bonded workers in Tamil Nadu state exceeded one million and even said that government figures are misleading and appear fabricated.

Only three of Sainath’s 68 stories are on education and he notes “there could have been a little more on education had there been a lit bit more education in the places where I went.”

India’s outlay on education has been steadily falling since independence. While the first five-year-plan gave education 7.8 percent of the total outlay, the second lowered it to 5.8 percent and by the fifth plan it was making do with 3.2 percent.

On the ground, that has resulted in schools such as the one Sainath discovered in Godda district, eastern India, which had eight classes, seven teachers, four students, two classrooms and one broken chair. “The chair, reserved for the headmaster, is vacant, its occupant having been suspended on charges of embezzlement.”

In another school nearby, “a black goat proves to be the solitary scholar in the primary school building. Two others sit patiently on the window sills.”

Sainath quotes authoritative sources to point out that as much as 60 percent of government funds for education go to a large number of elite, privately-owned schools which in fact are subsidised on public money. An attempt to evade the problem of providing primary education with the remaining funds has resulted in a system of “non-formal education” which has 250,000 “centres” across India where untrained instructors work an hour or two a day.

In central India, in Madhya Pradsh state which enrolled 700,000 children at such centres only 5 percent of the boys and 3 percent of the girls passed the fifth class. The health sector has fared worse. After independence, India committed 5 percent of its gross dopmestic Product (GDP) to health but gradually whittled this down to 1.7 percent. Only 20 percent of hospital beds are in rural areas although 80 percent of Indians live there.

Observes Sainath, “Many doctors after receiving a highly subsidised education, settle abroad to address the ailments of affluent Americans. So some of the most deprived, disease-ridden people subsidise the health of the richest.”

The result is that the rural poor are left to the mercy of quacks like Iqbal Qasim who styles himself as “doctor and surgeon” and practices in Palamau district in Bihar on the basis of a degree which combines “botany, biology, zoology, gynaecology and unani — a special course in allopathic medicine.”

Because allopathy is popular, “quacks” administer antibiotics and prescribe glucose-saline drip as magic cures for most ailments. In Orissa state, allopathic medicines are combined with witchcraft which involves the sacrifice of chickens.

Indeed such is the shortage of qualified medical personnel that in districts like Malkangiri witch-doctors are trained to handle drugs against malaria and diarrhoea. In contrast, metros like Bombay and Delhi have seen the growth of several luxury hospitals in which a week’s stay would cost the average annual income of most Indians.

Says Sainath, “Freedom brought major benefits to Indians. The problem begins when you look more closely at who cornered the gains of freedom. And how the poor have fared.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags