Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

LITERATURE: Vargas Llosa Opposes “Literature of Commitment”

Abraham Lama

LIMA, Jun 3 1997 (IPS) - In his new book, “Archaic Utopia,” renowned author Mario Vargas Llosa – an ex-socialist who delights in lambasting his former beliefs – attacks another highly-regarded Peruvian literary figure Jose Maria Arguedas.

Vargas Llosa gets right to the point with his book’s sub-title: “Jose Maria Arguedas and the Fiction of Indigenous Integrity.” According to Vargas Llosa, “indigenism” is an attempt to establish a delusional form of ideological conservatism and he says Arguedas favors “an archaic utopia that flies in the face of modernity.”

Vargas Llosa condemns the “literature of commitment” – one of his favorite targets since he abandoned the leftist politics of his university days, along with sympathy for the Cuban revolution.

In spite of its elegant, tightly argued prose – and the awesome database which Vargas Llosa deploys in support of his position – the central thesis is so peculiar to Peru, that the new publication probably will be ignored outside Peru.

But already Vargas Llosa’s assertions have provoked heated debate in his homeland.

Following his disappointing loss to Alberto Fujimori in the 1990 presidential elections, Vargas Llosa – in a fit of pique that his countrymen had voted for an “unknown agronomist of Japanese ancestry “- became a Spanish citizen. ‘Archaic Utopia’ is a continuation of Vargas Llosa’s argument with the Peruvian people, according to sociologist Daniel del Castillo.

In his new opus, Vargas Llosa attacks the entire intellectual establishment, savaging socialism (along with any other form of leftist ideology) as well as native American traditions.

Scholar Patricia Oliart notes that “the relationship which Vargas Llosa has conducted with the Andean world has always been difficult and distant. To me it seems egocentric that he denies the existence of something he hasn’t taken the trouble to understand. I think he has difficulty forgiving himself for having once been a leftist.”

While Vargas Llosa is well-known internationally, Arguedas’ fame has always been inside Peru. Arguedas died in 1969 at the age of 59 but a recent survey of writers, students and Peruvian politicians deemed his work indispensable to an understanding of Peru, especially this nation’s indigenous population.

“Indigenism” began in the 1920’s an intellectual and artistic movement to counter the official “hispanicism” which then dominated Peru. Its purpose was to demonstrate the worth of Peru’s indigenous population and native Quechua culture.

The most notable exponents of “indigenism” were artist Jose Sabogal, historian Luis Valcarcel, journalist Jose Carlos Mariategui – who founded the Peruvian Communist Party – and novelist and anthropologist Jose Maria Arguedas.

Arguedas was the Caucasian child of a judge who also was a large landholder. His mother died when he was three. The rest of his childhood was filled with the abuse of a tyrannical stepmother who made him eat and sleep with her servants. Out of this tormented childhood rose a bilingual author who thought in Quechua and wrote in Spanish.

Until the end of his life, Arguedas preferred the company of indigenous people over whites and mestizos who held social and political power.

“Agua” – a collection of stories – and four novels, “Yawar Fiesta” (“Yawar celebration”), “Los rios profundos” (“Deep rivers”), “Todas las sangres”

(“Every blood”) and “El zorro arriba y el zorro abajo” (“Fox up and fox down”) are fundamental texts if one wishes to understand the tormented vision of Peru’s native peoples.

Vargas Llosa recounts that Arguedas killed himself with a bullet to the forehead “while standing in front of a mirror to insure that his shot would be perfectly aimed.” Vargas Llosa portrays Arguedas as “desperate” over the 1968 suppression of the “Prague Spring” by Soviet tanks.

Vargas Llosa believes that “indigenism” is a dead-end street based on irrationality and magical thinking. It is, according to the author, a logical outcome of socialist utopian ideology. He says that Arguedas sacrificed his talent by enslaving himself to ideological objectives.

Sociologist Guillermo Nugent says that “Vargas Llosa wrote this book at age 59, the same age at which Arguedas killed himself. No doubt, Vargas Llosa – like Arguedas – will rendezvous with his own fate. I think he wrote this book in an attempt to finally finish a chapter in his life story.”

Nugent also refers to a suicide attempt by a character in Vargas Llosa’s “La orgia perpetua” (“Perpetual Orgy”) but says “that no critic is going to spend much time analyzing” this detail.

Another critic, Nicolas Yerbi, praises Vargas Llosa’s exhaustive research and tightly argued position, but believes it is an ideological trap for Vargas Llosa to pit modernity against indigenism.

Yerbi says that – in spite of his war against indigenism, two of Vargas Llosa’s least successful novels – “Lituma en los Andes” and “Historia de Mayta” – the author employs “neo-indigenist” plots, albeit with a right-wing orientation.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags