Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines

SOUTH ASIA: Musharraf-Vajpayee Chat Warms up Mood at Summit

Muddassir Rizvi

ISLAMABAD, Jan 5 2004 (IPS) - Pakistan President Gen Pervez Musharraf’s meeting with Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vayjpayee on the sidelines of the South Asian summit Monday – their first chat in nearly three years – has overshadowed the otherwise high-profile meeting underway here.

The international community and the press seem to be more interested in monitoring any progress in ties between rival neighbours India and Pakistan, the most powerful nations in the seven-nation bloc called the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC).

Its member countries – Bangladesh, Bhutan, Nepal, Sri Lanka and the Maldives – also attach high hopes on the thaw in Indo-Pakistan relations, which have long held the organisation hostage.

Vajpayee called the one-hour talk a ”courtesy call”, and a Pakistani official said ”detailed discussions” that ended ”on a positive note” were held between the two leaders.

”It is necessary that the two countries have adequate representation and that dialogue goes on continuously, that we understand each other’s difficulties and find a way out together,” Vajpayee said.

There is a long way ahead to repairing frosty ties between the two countries, whose relations have turned slightly warmer in the last few months, and both sides are wary of raising hopes too high.

Still, Monday’s meeting is being seen as the culmination of confidence building measures over the past months, including restoration of road, air and rail links – a far cry from recent years when India and Pakistan massed more than a million troops on their border and were on the brink of war.

In other words, the prospect of dividends of a more cordial relationship between the two South Asian nuclear rivals has many excited.

Nepalese Prime Minister Surya Bahadur Thapa says that improved India-Pakistan ties would relax tensions and provide "a new and meaningful impetus to cooperation among SAARC countries".

Even people in Pakistan are more concerned with Vajpayee’s presence in the city, hoping it will finally lead to something "positive’.

"I was so happy to see the picture in the newspaper of two prime ministers (Vajpayee and Pakistani Prime Minister Zafarullah Jamali, who had talks Sunday) waving to people, holding hands,” said Mohammad Hussain, a retired senior bureaucrat.

”This better sense should continue. We need to come out of the rut that has been plaguing us since we become independent in 1947," he said, referring to the year of the partition of the subcontinent along religious lines.

While religious parties, particularly those like Jamaat-i-Islami that support militancy in Indian-held Kashmir, maintain their hardline rhetoric of ‘no compromise’ with India, there have been public calls that Vajpayee address the people of Pakistan just as former U.S. President Bill Clinton did when he visited here in 2000.

"We need to inculcate mutual trust to ensure peace. For this, we will have to stop demonising the leaders of the two countries. Vajpayee should be requested to come and talk to the people of Pakistan," suggested an activist with the Pakistan-India Forum for Peace and Democracy.

"SAARC future hinges on Pak-India relations," said an editorial comment in an Urdu- language newspaper.

Founded 18 years ago, the association has been a non-starter in reinvigorating regional cooperation primarily due bilateral disputes.

Topping the list has been the five-decade-old Kashmir dispute between the nuclear neighbours, India and Pakistan, which has pushed the two countries to two wars in 1948 and 1965 and a smaller conflict in Kargil in 1999.

"SAARC can only become a viable and vigorous organisation playing a role in regional cooperation and development if its two major players sort out their issues or at least start a process to do that," commented Salim Bokhari, editor of the English-language daily ‘The News’.

A 30-minute meeting Sunday between Vajpayee and Jamali preceded the Monday talk between Musharraf and Vajpayee.

Meantime, the summit started discussion on a six-point agenda finalised by the foreign ministers of the seven member countries over the weekend.

The summit agenda includes a South Asian Free Trade Agreement, an additional summit protocol to the 1987 SAARC Convention on Suppression of Terrorism, social charter, poverty alleviation strategy and the concept of a South Asian Development Bank.

Any headway in operationalising the summit agenda after its approval, particularly the new clauses on anti-terrorism, will largely depend on the state of political ties among SAARC members – naturally that between India and Pakistan, commented Pervez Iqbal Cheema, who heads the Islamabad Policy Research institute. But then again, Bokhari commented: "A good sense is prevailing on both sides. By having setting aside the Kashmir dispute rhetoric, Pakistan has taken the first step to ensuring that SAARC summit could be utilised to start the bilateral talks process with its arch rival. The Indian response only shows its desire to get the ball rolling.”

In his opening statement to the three-day summit, Jamali said that the idea of establishing a South Asia economic union or monetary union would remain a distant dream unless the political environment in the region was addressed in a just and realistic manner.

Although these remarks were not new, he – interestingly – did not make customary mention of the Kashmir dispute.

"It is the stark reality of the political differences and disputes that has held back the prospects of real economic cooperation in South Asia," said Jamali. "We must realise that the vision could only be transformed into reality if we are able to overcome differences and disputes and create a climate of mutual trust and confidence.”

Vajpayee placed similar stress in his address, calling upon the South Asian nations to put aside their "petty disputes". "History can remind us, guide us or warn us. It should not shackle us. We have to look forward now, now with a collective approach in mind," he said.

The seeming attempt to look beyond politics was underlined by the South Asian leaders’ signing on Sunday of the social charter, which binds SAARC to establish a people-centred framework for social development.

But civil society groups say that South Asian nations must focus on peace building, which will lead to social and economic cooperation. A joint declaration issued by the assembly of civil society groups, which is meeting here on the summit’s sidelines, called on SAARC leaders to sign a ‘no war’ pact and declare South Asia as a nuclear-free zone.

The seven countries must reduce military expenditures and divert the savings to creating ”social securities”, argued Padma Rathnayeka, director of South Asia Partnership Sri Lanka.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags