Africa, Headlines

NIGERIA-MEDIA: Tighter Press Control in the Offing

Remi Oyo

IBADAN, Nigeria, Jan 23 1997 (IPS) - Decisions by Nigeria’s government to set up special press courts and enforce a decree requiring newspapers to apply for publishing licences each year have caused concern among media professionals in this West African country.

“Our own main grouse is that the newspaper registration decree is unnecessary because there are already enough laws that guide newspaper production,” Biodun Oduwole, editor-in-chief of the privately owned ‘Tribune Newspapers’, told IPS in the western city of Ibadan.

The difference with the decree ‘is that you will have to reapply every year for registration. If in one year you are adjudged to be unworthy of a licence, you don’t get it,” explained Oduwole, a former president of the Nigerian Guild of Editors (NGE).

Decree 43 was issued in 1993, but had not been enforced by Nigeria’s government. However, over the past month, Information and Culture Minister Walter Ofonagoro has hardly missed an opportunity to announce that it will now be implemented.

“Starting from this year, government has decided that all newspapers and magazines without exception will be duly registered,” he said in an interview published this week by the ‘Nigerian Tribune’ newspaper.

The decree states that applications for registration are to be made to a Newspapers Registration Board made up of eight presidential appointees. Each newspaper will have to pay a pre- registration deposit of 250,000 naira (about 3,100 U.S. dollars) and a non-refundable fee of 100,000 naira (1,250 dollars).

The applications must be submitted “together with evidence concerning the good character, competence and integrity of the directors and of other persons responsible for or in charge of the publication of the newspaper,” according to the decree.

It adds that “the registration of a newspaper … shall be subject to renewal every year on the payment of such a renewal fee as the Board may from time to time by regulations determine.”

That’s not the only condition: The license “may be renewed if the Board is satisfied with the performance of the newspaper during the preceding year,” reads the decree. “… if the renewal of registration is not completed within six weeks after the expiration of an existing registration, the newspaper shall cease to be published”.

For Oduwole, the measure will effectively limit press freedom. “It is some kind of blackmail, threat and censorship of the media which will prevent optimum performance because only a foolish editor will allow the de-registration of his newspaper,” he argued. “Since we are all accountable to our boards, no shareholder will be happy with an editor that allowed the closure of his investment.”

It’s not just journalists from the independent press who have come out against the decision to enforce the decree.

“…leaders of government or other political leaders do not think very highly of the press and they usually detest what is written, especially about them,” Garba Shehu, managing director of the state-owned ‘Triumph Newspapers’ in the northern town of Kano, told a recent forum of senior journalists and government officials.

But, “history teaches that censorship is the wrong answer and that the alternative to the justice system is anarchy,” said Shehu, who is also president of the NGE.

Negotiations between the NGE, the Newspaper Proprietors’ Association of Nigeria (NPAN), the Nigerian Union of Journalists (NUJ) and Ofonagoro have achieved nothing, with both the media and the information minister sticking to their positions.

Ofonagoro placed the blame on the media houses. “I held a series of meetings with the NPAN (in September 1995) where they stated that the fees charged are too high and they appealed for an amendment of the decree to make it affordable,” he was quoted as saying in this week’s interview.

“I said they should come up with their suggestion to the amendment so that I can convey this to the Federal Government,” he added. “Up till today, they have not come forward with the amendments. This means in effect they simply wanted to use delay tactics to make sure that the law is not enforced. That situation is no longer tolerable.”

The Lagos state chapter of the NUJ has initiated court action to stop the implementation of Decree 43, but neither the controversy over the decree, in general, nor the court case in particular, appears to have deterred Ofonagoro.

“Those who fail to comply (with the decree) including government-owned medium will face severe penalty,” he said.

According to the decree, the owner, publisher or printer of ” a newspaper which is not registered … is guilty of an offence and liable on conviction to a fine of 250,000 naira or imprisonment for a term not exceeding seven years or to both…”

For Oduwole, the answer to the threat of selective closure hanging over Nigeria’s newspapers is for “all the media to stand up and say no”.

“The NPAN, the NGE and the NUJ which control journalistic practice can order all newspapers to stop publishing,” he argued. “Unless that is done, the minister will successfully break the back of the media should he selectively implement the law.”

Oduwole also condemned a decision by Ofonagoro to set up press courts.

“I think the proposed press court is another manifestation of this government’s love for special courts,” Oduwole said. “The tragedy is that it weakens the influence of ordinary courts. What purpose is this press court going to serve? It will give the impression that the government is trying to muzzle the press.”

Other journalists and professional bodies such as the NUJ have also opposed the establishment of the courts, arguing that the Nigerian Press Council should be allowed to keep performing its function of settling disputes involving the media.

When he first announced the decision last month, Ofonagoro said provision for the courts, which would try all journalists who wrote false reports, would be made in an amendment to a decree that established the Nigerian Press Council.

Since the inauguration of its first board in December 1992, the council has adjudicated 58 complaints involving institutions, individuals and the electronic and print media.

These include a complaint filed by Ofonagoro against the private ‘National Concord’ daily in which, according to a council document made available to IPS, “the complainant said a report carried by the newspaper, titled ‘Busy Walter was there’ gave ‘a wrong impression that (he) was not invited to the opening ceremony” of a hotel …”

The decision did not go in Ofonagoro’s favour. According to the document, the council noted “that the National Concord has reflected the correction that the Minister was duly invited to the occasion in its Monday June 17, 1996 issue on page six. It therefore regards the complaint as having been resolved directly.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags