Saturday, November 21, 2026
Yuli Ismartono
- A series of recent riots which saw the burning down of Christian and Islamic places of worship, has raised serious questions regarding the much-venerated religious tolerance and national unity of multi-ethnic Indonesia.
One unanswered question is whether the incidents were motivated by religion or politics, or rather the political manipulation of religious ignorance.
“It is quite possible that misperceptions are being fanned by anti-religious factions as well as by groups who are against the country’s unity,” read a recent editorial in the daily ‘Republika’ newspaper.
In two instances toward the end of last year, Christian churches in Java were torched by Muslim mobs, and most recently, at the end of December, it was Madurese Muslim migrants in East Kalimantan who were the target of mostly-Christian Dayak tribesmen’s anger.
The Tasikmalaya riots in early December were sparked by reports of police brutality against some teachers of a nearby Muslim boarding school.
Similarly, last October in Situbondo, East Java, more than 20 churches were burnt down when rioters destroyed shops and offices amid protests that a Muslim tried for committing blasphemy against Islam, had got away with a light sentence by the presiding judge.
Still, officials say it is not an issue of religious intolerance, and that the riots were rather politically agitated by “third parties”.
According to Armed Forces Chief General Feisal Tanjung, the authorities have identified the perpetrators and are preparing a case against them. He has given no further details.
The National Commission on Human Rights has also stated that its own fact-finding team found evidence of a third party’s involvement — at least in the Tasikmalaya, West Java incident.
“Based on the evidence found — including banners and leaflets inciting people to protest — there is strong suspicion that a third party set in motion this social disturbance,” said commission director Munawir Sjadzali, a former Religious Minister in President Suharto’s cabinet.
A random survey conducted by the Centre for the Study of Development and Democracy (CESDA) in the cities of Medan, Surabaya and Bali, would also tend to suggest that the riots were not motivated by religion.
The study found that close to 90 per cent of the respondents claimed to have no problems living and associating with people of different religions, and would extend a helping hand to victims of riots, prompting CESDA director Rustam Ibrahim to conclude that religious tolerance and co-existence remained strong on the archipelago.
Still, some observers point out that religion is an extremely sensitive issue among Indonesia’s 200 million multi-ethnic and multi-cultural population, and everyone is usually extra careful not to do or say anything that would incite a negative reaction.
“There is a tendency to steer away from explanations that involve religious elements for fear of provoking divisions or cracks in the fragile unity among the diverse population,” said a sociologist in Jakarta.
The survey and the findings of the human rights commission still beg the question: who would be the likely third party behind the riots.
Armed Forces Chief, General Tanjung, has given no details about the government’s investigations.
In the past, when it came to charges of destabilisation, the army has usually pointed fingers at the Communist Party of Indonesia, which has been outlawed for the past 30 years. The government claims remnants of the party still exist in different forms to agitate against the establishment.
But some analysts say that the root problem of the issue may be neither religious nor political, but rather a response by the marginalised to persistent social and economic disparity.
In the absence of means to openly express disenchantment with their plight, analysts say the marginalised have little recourse other than to voice their anger and their frustration through protests which usually end up as riots.
Indonesia’s strong economic growth in recent years has gone some way to uplifting living standards, but millions continue to live below the poverty line.
A new strategy to eradicate poverty in Indonesia was unveiled in the 1997-98 budget plan. It includes a 110 per cent increase in funds allocated to the population and family welfare sectors. Allocations for the health and social sectors have also been boosted.
In the budget presentation, President Suharto also decreed the establishment of a supplementary diet programme to help provide food for some 7.5 million pupils from 49,000 public, and religious schools.