- Development & Aid
- Economy & Trade
- Human Rights
- Global Governance
- Civil Society
Saturday, October 25, 2014
- Kashmir’s juvenile justice system is sorely deficient for a state ridden with a long, and often violent, separatist conflict that attracts youth, say lawyers and rights activists. Kashmir has no juvenile home or specialised detention centre and applicable laws in the state deem anyone older than 16 years of age to be an adult.
The result is that young people, many of them under trial, are lodged in regular jails along with hardened criminals.
“This is completely illegal as India’s Juvenile Justice Act (JJA) of 2000 clearly bars juveniles from being kept in regular jails,” Syed Faisal Qadri, a well-known Srinagar lawyer, told IPS.
The JJA calls for a special approach towards prevention and treatment of juvenile delinquency and provides a framework for the protection and rehabilitation of children. This law, which conforms to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, is yet to be implemented in Kashmir.
Qadri links the non-implementation of the JJA in Kashmir to the ongoing conflict and the priority placed by the government on security. “Their priorities are low on child rights. This shows the insensitive attitude of the state towards its own children.”
“It seems that the government is avoiding implementation of the JJA so that it can continue to use tough laws like the Public Safety Act (PSA), which permit the preventive detention of children,” said Qadri. “Otherwise, there is no justification not to implement the JJA, ignoring favourable directions from the High Court.”
Qadri’s charges and the frailness of the juvenile justice system were palpable during a flare up of unrest of the summer of 2010 when hundreds of young people, many as young as 14, were detained for allegedly pelting stones at the police.
It took considerable effort on the part of the families of the minors and human rights organisations before they were granted bail or their detentions quashed by the courts.
Mushtaq Ahmad Sheikh, 14, was arrested for alleged stone pelting in April 2010 and booked under the PSA. He was granted bail after eight days, but was rearrested in the same month and finally released in February 2011.
“Mushtaq was innocent. He was made to suffer unnecessarily. He was only 14 years of age when picked up,” Mushtaq’s father, Ghulam Mohi-ud-din Sheikh, told IPS.
“Mushtaq quit studies and started working as a bus conductor and mechanic to help support the family,” the elder Sheikh said. “Mushtaq’s arrest not only deprived us of a son’s love but also reduced the meager income of a family with seven daughters.”
“The thought that Mushtaq would be tortured in custody haunted us through the long months that he was in custody,” said Sheikh. “We feared he would never be released.”
Faizaan Rafiq Hakeem, 15, who was booked under PSA in February, was released only after the intervention of Amnesty International. Harris Rasheed Langoo, 15, was detained in November 2010, despite being granted bail twice.
Murtaza Manzoor, aged 17, was released after three months in administrative detention after the state high court intervened and declared his imprisonment unlawful.
Though presently, no one below the age of 18 is in detention, scores of older youths are in jails on charges of stone pelting or violating prohibitive orders.
In March, the state government released figures which said 5,255 persons, including 799 students, were arrested across the state for alleged stone pelting during the unrest that ran between January 2010 and February 2011. Of these 264 continue to be in custody.
“It is a brutal fact that we do not have juvenile homes here. The teenagers and minors are put together with other criminals. This has a negative effect on children,” says B. A. Dabla, a sociologist who lectures at the University of Kashmir. “The children pick up the attitudes of the criminals and there is little chance of rehabilitation,” Dabla said. “Juveniles also face exploitation at the hands of other adult prisoners.”
Dabla said the implementation of the JJA in Kashmir without further delay was important because of the ongoing conflict in the state. “Our youth are exposed to the conflict and so many of them are unemployed.”
Mohammad Ayub, superintendent of the Srinagar district jail, told IPS that plans are being drawn up to build juvenile detention facilities and that he expects the age at which minors are deemed adults increased to 18 years.