Friday, November 20, 2026
Analysis - Dilip Hiro
- The decision by the U.S. Congress that the United States should move its embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem by May 1999 is both untimely and dangerously contentious.
According to the accord signed by Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organisation in Washington two years ago, the final status of Jerusalem is to be part of the final agreement on which talks between the two parties must begin by May 1996 and finish within the next two years.
By instructing the American president to make a move on Jerusalem, which is indisputably pro-Israeli, before the negotiations on the fate of the Holy City have even started, the U.S. Congress is undermining the position of the White House as an honest, impartial broker between the rival camps.
In international law the special position of Jerusalem derives from U.N. General Assembly Resolution 181 passed in November 1947 which stipulated partition of Palestine, then under the mandate of Britain, as decided by the League of Nations, the predecessor of the United Nations, in 1922.
The partition plan demarcated an Arab zone, a Jewish zone, and a zone covering Jerusalem and its environs to be put under international control, with the status of ‘corpus separatum’ (separate body), open to both the Arab and Jewish states.
Since then, mainly due to the Arab-Israeli wars of 1948 and 1967, the boundaries of the Arab and Jewish sectors have not coincided with the 1947 U.N. partition plan, the Arab/Palestinian zone, at 23 percent of British Palestine is about half of what it would have been under the U.N. partition plan.
But the international community has respected the ‘corpus separatum’ status of Jerusalem, which is holy to that half of humanity that believes in the major monotheistic religions of Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Therefore when the government of the Jewish state of Israel, established in 1948 with its capital in Tel Aviv, shifted its capital to Jerusalem in early 1949, none of the countries, which had recognised Israel and set up embassies in Tel Aviv, followed suit.
This has been the case with all the members of the international community, excepting two small Latin American states of Costa Rica and El Salvador.
All the nine Western nations, including the United States, Britain and France (three of the five permanent members of the U.N. Security Council), which have diplomatic presence in Jerusalem, maintain parallel consulates in East Jerusalem and West Jerusalem.
These consulates do not report to their respective embassies in Tel Aviv but directly to the foreign ministry at home. That is, these nations continue to respect ‘corpus separatum’ status of the Holy City.
One of the major problems about Jerusalem today is basic: what exactly constitutes Jerusalem?
From 1949 to June 1967 the Israeli government maintained its capital in West Jerusalem, measuring 35 sq. km. During that period East Jerusalem, 6.5 sq. km. in area and part of the West Bank, was under the control of Jordan.
During the Six Day Arab-Israeli War in early June 1967, Israel captured East Jerusalem as well as the rest of the West Bank, and occupied the territory. The international community, as presented by the U.N. Security Council, regarded Israel as the occupying military power.
Israel is therefore required to respect the Fourth Geneva Convention on War ‘Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War’. Its Article 49 (6) states: “The Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies.”
In violation of this Convention, in late June 1967 Israel annexed East Jerusalem, united it with West Jerusalem, and declared the unified city as its capital, and set on a course of establishing Jewish settlements in the eastern sector.
What Israel annexed was not merely East Jerusalem as it existed under the Jordanian administration, but an area was eleven times the size of that town. The annexed Israeli East Jerusalem measured 73.7 sq. km. — including the Mount Scopus enclave, measuring 2 sq. km., it had held between 1948 and 1967.
Since then Israel has established 12 Jewish settlements in the expanded East Jerusalem. It has done so by expropriating nearly one third of the total area. Of this land 82 percent was owned by the Palestinians.
By providing local tax exemption to Jews for five years, followed by lower taxation than in West Jerusalem, the Israeli authorities have attracted residents to these Jewish settlements. As a result, officials began claiming in 1993 that the Jewish population of East Jerusalem at 155,000 had surpassed the Arab population at 150,000.
The Israeli-PLO negotiations on the final agreement will also include the status of the Jewish settlements in the Palestinian territories of the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and the enlarged East Jerusalem.
All this highlights the highly contentious and complex nature of the Jerusalem issue.
The complexity of the subject is further illustrated by the fact that while the Israeli government is pleased to have the U.S. Congress backing for its policy of consolidating its hold over all of Jerusalem, now measuring 108.7 sq. km., it is lukewarm about the details.
The U.S. Congress resolution instructs the president to move the U.S. embassy to the site that the United States owns in West Jerusalem. This has not gone well among the cabinet members of Israel.
The seriousness of Congressional action was obvious to all, including President Bill Clinton, who had threatened to veto the bill. That is why the president and Congressional leaders worked out an escape clause. It authorises the president to issue a waiver for six months at a time on the ground of “national security”.
Given this, observers wonder what exactly was the purpose of the exercise. One theory is that Senator Bob Dole, the front-runner in the Republican nomination for president, and the leading force behind the Congressional move, is actively courting Jewish vote and, more importantly, Jewish money for his campaign.
If so, to be playing with one of the most contested issues in the world for partisan, domestic purposes reflects poorly on the calibre and judgement of a senior U.S. politician in particular and on U.S. electoral politics in general.
Analysis - Dilip Hiro
- The decision by the U.S. Congress that the United States should move its embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem by May 1999 is both untimely and dangerously contentious.
(more…)