Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines | Analysis

AGRICULTURE: A Return to the Roots Could Prevent a Food Crisis

Analysis - Martin Khor

PENANG, Malaysia, Mar 28 1996 (IPS) - Mounting concerns about food security and of the diminishing diversity of agricultural crops are key issues to be addressed at two high-level United Nations meetings to be held this year.

An international conference on plant genetic resources will be held in Leipzig, Germany in June, and the World Food Summit in Rome in November. Both are organised by the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO).

International experts will among others things, examine the effect of different agriculture technologies on the environment and on food supplies. But while much of the spotlight may be on new techniques, the solution to a future potential crisis may well lie in traditional crop farming.

The search for new farming methods follows disillusionment in the Green Revolution which has over the past three decades promoted the use of seeds with a high response to big doses of inorganic fertiliser and chemical pesticides.

The problem with this is it has been found that the few seed varieties have displaced a wide range of traditional seeds, thus eroding crop biodiversity.

Moreover, in areas where the model has operated for a longer period, there is evidence of declining yields. According to the head of the FAO’s regional office for Asia and the Pacific, Obaidullah Khan, there is now sufficient evidence that the Green Revolution model is not sustainable.

Khan revealed that recent statistics had shown a yield decline of one to three per cent per year on some fields using the Green Revolution technique, a situation which was described as “a recipe for disaster within one generation” by the FAO regional officer for integrated pest control, Dr Peter Kenmore.

Developments on some of the best managed experimental farms in Asia have added to the pessimism.

A recent article in International Agricultural Development (a London-based magazine) reports that on test plots at the Philippines-based International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), varieties which yielded 10 tons a hectare in 1966 are yielding less each year and now produce below seven tons per hectare.

There is also growing concern with other ecological problems, such as increasing soil infertility, chemical pollution of land and water resources, pesticide poisoning, and pest infestation due to growing pest immunity to pesticides.

So what are the alternative solutions for food security?

Some aid donors, commercial companies, universities and private research foundations have already began to channel funds into biotechnological research even though some of the claimed benefits of genetic engineering are far from being proven, whilst there is increasing evidence of real and potential risks.

In a recent statement, an international group of scientists pointed out scientific flaws of the genetic engineering paradigm, showing why it is impossible to predict the consequences of transferring a gene from one type of organism to another in a significant number of cases.

According to the scientists’ statement, the more specific risks in agriculture are that some transgenic crops could become noxious weeds, and others could become a conduit through which new genes may move to wild plants which themselves could then become weeds.

There is also a possibility of new viral strains giving rise to new plant diseases.

Another report by an independent group of experts titled ‘Biosafety: Scientific Findings and the Need for a Protocol’ (July 1995), raises the possibility of certain genetically-engineered bacteria unintentionally killing soil organisms, thus reducing nutrient supply to plants.

This report and the scientists’ statement reinforce the conclusions of other experts and of environmental groups that the transfer to developing countries of projects or experiments involving genetic engineering could be hazardous — at least until safety regulations are put in place in these countries.

There is also the well-justified concern that the development of the new biotechnologies will develop food products which would displace the traditional export commodities of the South.

Consequently, some experts say that aid agencies should not yield to the temptation of chanelling much of their resources to developing the new biotechnologies as a new technological panacea for rapidly increasing yields in developing countries.

Instead, they say a case is to be made for sustainable agriculture, making use of traditional indigenous peoples’ farming techniques.

There is a prevailing premise that whilst ‘sustainable agriculture’ may be good in preserving the environment, it is inferior and grossly inadequate in terms of productivity and thus cannot be relied on to feed the increasing population.

Some scientists and ecologists in the Asian region point out that this premise could be based on prejudice, for there is evidence that ecological farming can be high yielding as well, indeed higher yielding than the Green Revolution method.

In India, Dr Vandana Shiva, head of the Research Foundation for Science and Ecology, has pioneered studies comparing the Green Revolution and traditional farming methods.

She cites the studies showing that indigenous varieties “…fall in or above minimum limits set for high yields and these methods of cultivation deserve full attention”.

“In South India, in semi-arid tracts of the Deccan, yields went up to 5,000 kg/ha under tank and well irrigation. Under intensive manuring, they could go even higher,” she says.

There is now a great flowering of organic farming practices in many parts of India. Recently the Karnataka State Farmers’ Union set up an International Institute for Sustainable Agriculture to train farmers to switch from conventional chemical-based agriculture to organic farming.

The union’s deputy president, Baba Goweda Patel, has himself made the switch.

In 1991, using the conventional chemicalised system, he grew 15 acres of sorghum with an average output of five quintiles per acre. In 1992, when he stopped using chemicals and went organic he found he could still get five quintiles per acre, but by saving on fertiliser and pesticide, his net income increased.

By 1994, his organic farm was thriving, with output of nine quintiles an acre. Three years after conversion to organic agriculture, Baba’s farm was showing increases of 80 per cent in productivity and 170 per cent in net income.

Now, 500 farmers in his village have switched, at least partly, to organic farming.

In the Philippines, host country of the Green Revolution, several sustainable agriculture experiments are also being conducted by farmers, scientists and environmental groups that have reaped similar success.

“Policy-makers are still chasing after new technological miracles to feed the world, and ignoring the indigenous knowledge of farming communities and the broad diversity of nature’s resources,” laments the Malaysia-based Third World Network (TWN), a NGO that recently published a paper on the issue.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags