Asia-Pacific, Headlines

INDIA: Conflict In The Cradle Of Buddhism

Kalinga Seneviratne

BODHGAYA, India, Oct 6 1996 (IPS) - It was here, legend has it, that an Aryan prince named Siddhartha, while meditating under the shade of a tree more than 25 centuries ago, obtained the divine knowledge which inspired him to found one of Asia’s main religions.

To millions of Buddhists across the world, Bodhgaya in India’s most backward state of Bihar where the Buddha attained ‘Nirvana’ (enlightenment), is the holiest shrine.

Thousands of Buddhists from other countries travel to Bodhgaya every year which has become one of India’s biggest tourist draw for visitors mainly from Southeast Asia and Japan.

However, in recent years, a more than century-old dispute between local Buddhists and Hindus for the control of the shrine is boiling over with the former accusing the latter of ‘Hinduising’ the Maha Bodhi shrine.

The conflict has become politicised with the involvement of local leaders of the pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party, India’s main parliamentary opposition party.

Indian Buddhist organisations are planning a big protest rally on Nov. 1 in New Delhi when they will hand over a petition to the Prime Minister, asking him to change a half century-old law which is said to have legitimised Hindu control of the shrine.

Local Buddhists feel helpless because the they have hardly any political voice in the country. Though the religion originated in India, Buddhists make up less than one hundredth of the 900 million people in the country. Most of them were actually low- caste Hindus who converted in the last 40 years.

Treated as untouchables by those higher up in the complex Hindu socio-religious order, the lower castes switched religious loyalty under the inspiration of B.R. Ambedkar who was one of the founders of the Indian repubic and a key architect of the country’s Constitution.

Himself a low caste Hindu, Ambedkar inaugurated the mass conversions in October 1956 by embracing Buddhism. More than 400,000 other low caste Hindus followed him.

Their low-caste origins are a vital factor in the conflict, says Sri Lankan-born Buddhist monk, Ven M.Wimalasara who is in charge of the Maha Bodhi Centre for pilgrims and is living in Bodhgaya for the past 15 years

The low caste associations of the religion in India have been an obstacle to its growth in the country, he admits, because the upper castes are reluctant to convert.

Traditionally, the religion was practised by the tribal communities living all along the country’s Himalayan border from the northwest to the northeast.

“These people have no power at all in India. But, the new Buddhists (the followers of Ambedkar) do have a strong political voice,” he says.

This voice is coordinated through the Bodhgaya Mahabodhi Mahavihar All India Action Committee (MAC) led by two Buddhist monks. They are Japanese-born, naturalised Indian, Ven Nagarjuna Shurei Sasai and Ven Bhadant Anand. Both live in far away Nagpur in India’s southwestern Maharashtra state.

The dispute over the Maha Bodhi shrine goes back to the 19th century when colonial British rulers are alleged to have favoured upper caste Hindu priests in helping them gain control of the Buddha temple.

Buddhists say the images of Buddha have since been given the appearance of Hindu gods and the temple made a centre of Hindu pilgrimage.

A few years after independence from British rule in 1947, the Indian government enacted the Bodhgaya Temple law under which the shrine is managed by a eight-member committee of four Buddhists and four Hindus. The chairman of the panel has to be a Hindu and is the top district administrative official in Bodhgaya. If he is not a Hindu the government nominates another.

But, Buddhists were quick to point out that this gave a majority of one to the Hindus in the management of the temple.

The Buddhist campaign turned agitationist four years ago, peaking in a four-day hunger protest last year by MAC leader Ven Sasai. He was persuaded to call it off by Bihar chief minister Laloo Prasad Yadav who promised to make changes in the management of the shrine.

But angry Buddhists say they have been let down by Yadav who later said this could only be done the central overnment in New Delhi.

“He said at that time that he is ready to change the Act. But, now he says that the political situation is such, his government will collapse if he tries to change it,” senior monk Ven Pragyasheel told IPS.

Instead, in July last year, the Bihar chief minister nominated four Buddhist monks representing the Ambedkar Buddhists to the managing committee for the first time.

But this has split the Buddhists, with a section criticising those who accepted the nominations to the committee. “It has worked and people now ask why did they accept it. Did they lead the movement to get that membership,” says a Buddhist leader, who does not want to be named.

“Monks should not accept office and if they do they should give some part to Upasakas (lay followers),” says P.C.Roy, a local Buddhist and a former member of the managing panel.

“We were reluctant to join,” admits Ven Pragyasheel who was one of the four nominated. “But we were advised to get in and create a better environment in the management,” he says.

Ven Pragyasheel insists that the aim of their movement is to destroy the caste system in India. “It is because of that the Hindu leaders hate the converts” he notes.

Local BJP leader, Lalan Singh, who teaches in Bihar’s Magadh University, denies the Buddhist charge that Hindus are subverting their religion. He argues that there is no difference between Hindus and Buddhists.

“We have always said that Lord Buddha was the 10th reincarnation of Lord Vishnu (the Preserver in the Hindu Divine Trinity of Creator, Preserver and Destroyer). So Buddhists and Hindus are both from the same sect,” he says.

This view is supported by Dwarko Sundarani, the secretary of the Maha Bodhi management committee for more than 30 years. “Buddha was a Hindu. He lived as a Hindu, he died as a Hindu,” he says.

BJP leader Singh accuses the Buddhists in the management committee of trying to wrest control of the shrine to stop the Hindus worshipping there and says they want to make money out of tourism.

Monk Ven Pragyaseel agrees that money is largely to blame for the problem, but accuses the Hindus in turn of trying to pocket the tourism earnings.

He claims to have documentary evidence of the managing committee concealing the actual donations to the shrine in the last 40 years. Among these is a large donation by an Indonesian pilgrim group, he alleges.

“There is millions of rupees coming from Buddhist countries to develop Bodhagaya. But, the government is using this money to improve Hindu monasteries and their community facilities and for election purposes,” he charges.

More than 20 Buddhist monasteries have been built here by foreign countries. Work underway include an airport and hotels.

Local Buddhists are now supported by co-religionists abroad, like the Thailand-based World Fellowship of Buddhists, representing 40 countries which at its annual meet last year, passed a resolution backing the demand for handing over the Bodhgaya shrine to Buddhists.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags