Environment, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: Scientists Have Good And Bad News For The Tiger

Dipankar De Sarkar

LONDON, Feb 21 1997 (IPS) - The world’s top tiger experts ended two days of deliberations here Friday, making it clear that scientists, law enforcement agencies and politicians would have to work better together if efforts to save the endangered big cat are to succeed.

The Tiger 2000 symposium, organised by the Zoological Society of London, drew some 25 scientists and conservationists for what was billed as the first major scientific meeting dedicated to tigers in over a decade.

Their presentations made it clear that any effort to save the tiger had to adopt a multidisciplinary approach, including targeting the trade in pseudo-medications made of tiger body parts, exchanging scientific data and exploring new and better ways of conservation.

“We held the symposium now because the situation for tigers is desperate,” said Richard Burge, Director General of the Zoological Society of London.

There is little doubt that the lot of the tiger has worsened in the ten years since leading scientists last met at Minnesota in the United States to exchange up to date tiger data.

Then, there were some 200 tigers in South China. Now, there are a pitiful 20 — a number so low that the Chinese authorities, usually reticent about publicising such matters, publicly admit their extinction is imminent, according to one conservationist at the symposium.

Then, India’s Project Tiger was praised the world over as a success and model. Now, conservationists are less sure.

The Indian government says there is a problem but estimate the tiger population at between 3,000 and 4,750. Independent experts say the figure could be as low as 2,500. Some pessimists predict the Indian tiger will disappear in just three years as the pressure of human population growth squeezes the big cats’ natural habitats.

And in the last ten years, an internationally illegal trade in tiger body parts — destined for east Asian makers of ‘traditional’ medications — has massively expanded. Illegal trade in the body parts of protected endangered species like the tiger now runs second only to the narcotics trade in scale and value worldwide.

But at the same time, there has been immense scientific progress made in the area of conservation. This, the symposium revealed, is a fact that is often overlooked in the popular perception that the tiger is doomed to extinction.

“In scientific terms, we have moved on a lot since 1986,” said Alexandra Dixon, Director of Field Conservation at the Zoological Society of London. Two areas of science that in particular have come to the aid of animal and plant conservation recently are molecular biology and genetics.

Scientists now carry out Population Viability Analyses, which look at reproductive behaviour and trends, and the ‘camera-trap’, triggered by an infrared beam to photograph animals in the wild, wasn’t there for conservationists in 1986.

“What we need is information — the best possible information,” Dixon said. “We can’t afford to take shots in the dark. We need to collaborate in a joint international effort, and I know it’s a tall order.”

Scientists who have been studying population trends are worried about India — they say a lack of administrative and political will has meant that conservation efforts have come to nothing.

“It’s not the absolute numbers that matter — its the trend in population,” said Sarah Christie, the Zoological Society’s ‘tiger coordinator’. A large population of tigers with a declining trend in reproduction is thus more worrying to the experts than smaller groups with stable population growth.

They are also worried about another trend — increasing pressure from human activity on protected forest areas — has led to sub- groups breaking up into even smaller groups. This in turn leads to inbreeding and the loss of genetic variation.

Conservation biology is still a young science, says Morris Gosling, the Society’s director of science. And it needs huge resources.

“Rich countries can certainly contribute their scientific resources. In many cases in developing countries, these resources simply do not exist. For instance, the hardware for DNA fingerprinting is very expensive,” Gosling added.

Not all the concerns are scientific: the World Bank representative at the symposium was criticised by some Indian delegates who said the Bank had ignored Indian non-governmental organisations (NGOs) while drawing up its Ecodevelopment Project for India.

The 67 million dollar project, funded by the Bank’s Global Environment Facility, includes seven tiger reserves in India, but NGOs say neither they nor locals have been consulted.

Ashok Kumar, Vice President of the Wildlife Protection Society of India, said one of the controversial proposals of the project is to offer money to people living in and around the seven tiger reserves.

“We told them that this will have the exact opposite effect — more people will move in just for the money. In fact, many of us wondered whether by Ecodevelopment, the Bank meant economic development,” Kumar said.

Valmik Thapar, a high-profile Indian campaigner and Vice chairman (Asia) of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature, told Bank global environment biodiversity consultant Kathy MacKinnon that there have been 86 interventions to the World Bank from Indian NGOs, but the Bank has “either given unsatisfactory replies or not bothered to reply at all.

“Many of us feel that a lot of money is being thrown into seven projects,” Thapar added. MacKinnon refuted the charge and said the process had been participatory, though she would consider all conclusions from the meeting on this matter.

But despite it all, it’s not curtains yet for the feared predator. Scientists feel that the good news — if it can be called that — comes from countries that have fewer tigers, like Russia and Indonesia.

The latest (spring 1996) census suggest there may be up to 474 Amur tigers, also known as the Siberian tiger. Though this marks an increase on previous estimates, field workers warn that this was the most thorough census yet, and it could simply be a case of looking harder and finding more.

Similarly, the number of Sumatran tigers in Indonesia has been revised upward to about 500 after a 15-month exercise ending December 1996 to photograph tigers in the Way Kambas national park with infrared-activated automatic cameras.

Burge summed it up: “There is a particularly chilling phrase we scientists have where we say that ‘a species has committed itself to extinction’,” he said. “We have yet not reached that point with the tiger.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Environment, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: Scientists Have Good And Bad News For The Tiger

Dipankar De Sarkar

LONDON, Feb 21 1997 (IPS) - The world’s top tiger experts ended two days of deliberations here Friday, making it clear that scientists, law enforcement agencies and politicians would have to work better together if efforts to save the endangered big cat are to succeed.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags