Sunday, November 22, 2026
Analysis - By Antoaneta Bezlova
- While China’s voluntary imposition of export duties on garments might have averted the first global trade war in 2005 over textiles, it is unlikely to halt its rapid domination of the world clothing market.
While China’s voluntary imposition of export duties on garments might have averted the first global trade war in 2005 over textiles, it is unlikely to halt its rapid domination of the world clothing market.
Beijing got a poignant reminder that its pre-emptive tariffs on the country’s garment exports were nothing more than symbolic.
”Putting a few cents tax on exports,” was unlikely to have ”any meaningful kind of impact to the ultimate structure of the textile industry in the world,” U.S. Commerce Secretary Donald Evans said in Beijing this week. ”The economic forces are basically too powerful.”
On Jan. 1, the 30-year-old complex system of quotas limiting imports of textiles and clothing into developed-world markets came to an end. China, which currently makes around 20 percent of the world’s textile goods, is expected to gain mightily from the ending of quotas – doubling its share of the market by 2007.
In an apparent attempt to appease global fears that the country would dominate the world clothing market, Beijing announced last month that most of its textile goods would be taxed at two U.S. cents per item across 148 types of clothing.
”The main message to our fiends in Beijing is that China’s role in the world economy is changing – there is an obligation that goes along with the role to which China aspires (to play) in the world trading system and the world economy as a whole,” Grant Aldonas, the U.S. under secretary of commerce for international trade, who is accompanying Evans to Beijing, said.
Although the decision for terminating quotas for textiles was adopted 10 years ago (at the 1994 Uruguay trade round), recent months have seen an increasing number of textile industries – in both rich and poor countries – lobbying governments to implement fresh measures to keep down the volume of imports from China.
In anticipation that China will take advantage of the new trade regime and move to dominate the market, 72 textile and apparel groups from 36 countries have asked the World Trade Organisation (WTO) to extend the quota-free deadline until Dec. 31, 2007.
In December, the Argentinean government decided to adopt in January 2005 two decrees on restricting Chinese textile imports by imposing product quotas. The regulating decrees stipulate that imports of Chinese textile products and garments should not exceed 7.5 percent and six percent respectively of the total imports of similar products in the previous year.
The decision comes on top of already existing restrictions on Chinese textile products that industry experts say have made trade between the two countries very difficult.
Also in December, Turkey said it would impose quotas on 42 types of Chinese textile imports.
The damage caused by China’s emergence as a textile giant could be particularly devastating for smaller developing countries with less diversified economies, especially in Africa.
At the start of the New Year, the U.S. International Trade Commission issued a report on the impact of quota termination, identifying Lesotho, Kenya and Mauritius as particularly vulnerable.
In the U.S., industry experts estimate that the country could lose 600,000 jobs if action is not taken to control Chinese textile imports.
The Bush administration has been under growing pressure to consider imposing safeguard measures against apparel like shirts, blouses, trousers, dresses and some underwear, as well as home furnishings like cotton towels and sheets. Beijing agreed to allow such safeguards under the terms of its entry into the WTO.
The European Union, which has been a large market for Chinese textile goods for the past three years, used last month’s Seventh China-EU summit between European leaders and Chinese Prime Minister Wen Jiabao to press for steps that will keep the industry in check.
Threatened with a jump in ”anti-surge” proceedings filed at the WTO against its low- cost textile imports after Jan. 1, it was perhaps not surprising that Beijing decided to take the initiative by imposing its own tariffs on clothing.
According to Cao Xinyu, deputy director of the China Chamber of Commerce for Import and Export of Textiles, it sends a ”new signal” to the global markets that China intends to act responsibly, in consideration of its status as an emerging world power.
Chinese textile exporters have long been dogged by charges of unfair low-cost competition and dumping. And China’s former WTO negotiator Long Yongtu has warned that accusations against the country’s unfair market practices in its textile trade could have a long-lasting damaging effect on the industry – outweighing its real gains in profits and market share.
Recognition of this transpired in a December ‘China Daily’ article which reported on the government’s decision to impose textile quotas. The article said that at a closed-door meeting concerning the post-quota period in October, 70 to 80 percent of 400 Chinese textile company representatives agreed that they ”would support stricter industry management after the quotas are lifted.”
But given that China’s textile and garment industries are already among the world’s most efficient, a two U.S. cent increase in costs is not going to take the competitive edge off Chinese exports.
Analysis - By Antoaneta Bezlova
- While China’s voluntary imposition of export duties on garments might have averted the first global trade war in 2005 over textiles, it is unlikely to halt its rapid domination of the world clothing market.
(more…)