Asia-Pacific, Civil Society, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines, Poverty & SDGs

ENVIRONMENT: Loggers Lose in Court but Pursue Green Groups

Bob Burton

CANBERRA, Aug 18 2005 (IPS) - Despite a series of setbacks in court, one of Australia’s largest forestry companies is pressing ahead with legal action against 20 environmentalists and green groups alleging a ”conspiracy” to damage its business and seeking some 5.2 million US dollars in damages.

In part of its claim, the Tasmania-based company ‘Gunns’ alleges that lobbying by the environmentalists with three Japanese pulp and paper companies – Mitsubishi Paper Mills, Nippon Paper Industries and Oji Paper – had ”maliciously interfered” with their business through ”unlawful means”.

But at a Victorian Supreme Court hearing on the case, Wednesday, Justice Bernard Bongiono directed the company to pay the environmentalists a substantial portion of costs incurred in defending the legal case to date.

On Dec.14, 2004 Gunns lodged a 216-page writ against the 20 defendants, which included Australian senator, Bob Brown, a Tasmanian member of state parliament, Peg Putt, a doctor, two film-makers and the national environmental group, The Wilderness Society, and a number of smaller local environmental groups.

A central element in Gunn’s claim termed the ‘Japanese Customers Action’ was that lobbying between December 2000 and March 2004 of the Japanese companies was designed to ”injure” Gunns.

The Japanese companies account for approximately 95 percent of Gunns woodchip exports of approximately five million tonnes a year.

At the heart of the controversy is the logging of the remaining significant stands of Tasmania’s old-growth forests for matchbox-sized woodchips used in paper making.

In March, Mitsubishi announced that it would no longer buy woodchips from old-growth forests. More worrying for Gunns is the prospect that Nippon Paper Industries, which is estimated to account for as much as 40 percent of Gunns woodchip exports, may follow the lead of Mitsubishi.

Earlier this year Nippon Paper Industries wrote to Gunns and Tasmanian Premier Paul Lennon, urging them to ”conclude this divisive debate” over the logging of native forests. Between mid-June and mid-July the company, called for public comments on its raw materials procurement policy.

In the writ, Gunns complained that demonstrations, media releases and letters to the three Japanese companies had the effect of senior officers of Mitsubishi giving ”serious consideration to ceasing to purchase” its woodchips.

In July, the 20 defendants, who have adopted the name the ‘Gunns 20′, applied to the court to have the case thrown out due to the vague claims in the initial writ. Justice Bongiono largely accepted the environmentalists’ complaints and told the company that unless it submitted a ”radically altered” version of its claim within 28 days the case would be struck out.

In his decision, Bongiono described Gunns’ claims relating to the impact of environmentalists lobbying on the three Japanese customers as ”embarrassing”. ”The part of the plaintiffs’ case designated as the Japanese Customers Action cannot be permitted to proceed in its present form,” he wrote.

Earlier this week, Gunns re-submitted a new 221-page statement of claim that increased the amount of damages sought by 282,000 US dollars.

Bongiono gave the defendants a month to seek clarification on the claims against them and told Gunns, despite their plea for more time, it must respond within six weeks.

However, outside the court, senator Brown was scathing about Gunns plea for more time. ”I thought they had their case ready on Dec.14 last year. Now they’re saying it’s oppressive for them not to get a couple of more weeks,” he told ABC Radio.

While the court accepted Gunns latest statement of claim, lawyers for the Gunns 20 have signalled their intention to apply to have the entire claim struck out. The next hearing on the case may not be until December or early next year. Gunns declined to publicly comment while the case is before the courts.

The tide has been running against Gunns on other fronts too. Late July, a motion describing Gunns legal writ as ”an attack on basic civil liberties and freedom of speech” was passed by the British parliament. The motion went on to congratulate Mitsubishi Paper Mills for its decision to cease buying woodchips from native forests and urged Nippon to follow suit.

Presently, almost one-third of the global woodchip trade is met by the logging of Australian native forests, mostly in Tasmania. However, industry analysts point to an emerging glut of woodchips from Tasmanian blue gums grown in South American plantations as likely to undermine the Australian industry.

Underlying the cutbacks of old-growth woodchips is the fact that companies making white paper products increasingly prefer woodchips from much younger plantations than those sourced from the more controversial older forests.

In a July submission to a parliamentary inquiry Australian National University forestry analyst, Judy Clark, argued that with the volume of Australian woodchips set to double in the near future there is scope to end the logging of native forests. ”Switching Australia’s commodity- based forest industry from native forest wood to plantation wood is a desirable public policy goal,” she wrote.

Spokeswoman for The Wilderness Society, Virginia Young, is confident that the defendants will ultimately win through. ”Gunns have had two significant raps over the knuckles and some very strong signals from the Supreme Court that they are not very happy with the manner in which the case is being conducted,” she said.

 
Republish | | Print |