Sunday, November 22, 2026
Sebastián Lacunza
- Argentine President Néstor Kirchner has kept his popularity ratings high thanks at least in part to effective management of the economy and the reduction of poverty, although the country is still far from meeting the Millennium Development Goals.
Official projections indicate that gross domestic product (GDP) will have grown by a total of nearly 40 percent between the May 2003 start of the centre-left Kirchner administration and Dec. 10, 2007, when it comes to an end.
In the meantime, poverty will have fallen in the same period from 52 percent to 27 percent of the population of 37 million, and according to the Equis polling firm, extreme poverty will have dropped to 8.7 percent of the population.
Although the proportion of people living in extreme poverty is equivalent to one-third of the proportion in mid-2002, at the height of the crisis that followed the late-2001 economic and political meltdown, there is still a long way to go before Argentina returns to the strong performance indicators of the past.
Claudio Katz, a professor of economics at the public University of Buenos Aires, downplayed the merits of the Kirchner administration, saying the positive indicators do not reflect specific policies implemented by the current government.
“I would not attribute the growth figures to merits of the government, but to changes in the economic cycle, which have provided Argentina with conditions that are more favourable than anything seen in the past 50 years,” he told IPS.
Figures on tax collection, the budget surplus, foreign reserves and exports have led the government to project optimism, with a certain degree of social consensus. Wages and income distribution are gradually improving and unemployment has dropped to 10.2 percent, after soaring to 22 percent at the height of the economic crisis.
Only inflation remains a problem, reaching 9.8 percent last year.
But Katz argued that these achievements are only relative, given that the country had “descended into hell,” as Kirchner likes to say, with an unprecedented drop in GDP of more than 20 percent between 1999 and 2002.
The crisis was the worst in the history of Argentina, where in the 1970s, less than 10 percent of the population was below the poverty line, while just two percent lived in extreme poverty, and which in previous decades had better human development indicators than the European average.
In the wake of the 1976-1983 dictatorship, the poverty rate reached 15 percent in the 1980s, and climbed to 25 percent in the mid-1990s, as a consequence of runaway inflation in the first place and of high unemployment later, under the government of Carlos Menem (1989-1999), a staunch advocate of the free market.
Argentina had fallen into a deep recession by the end of Menem’s two successive terms in office, and the situation continued to go downhill until nationwide protests brought down the government of centrist president Fernando de la Rúa in December 2001, in the midst of an economic debacle.
The projection of 27 percent poverty for 2006 by the government statistics institute, Indec, means the rate is just now dropping to the levels seen during the recession of the 1990s – in other words, nothing to write home about.
Within the framework of the discussion on the eight United Nations Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) adopted by the international community in 2000, which include a commitment to halving the poverty rate from 1990 levels by 2015, many observers in Argentina are now debating how to reduce hardcore poverty.
“The problem I see is that we have gone from poverty in a context of crisis to poverty in a context of economic recovery. Poverty used to be primarily a problem of unemployment, but is now mainly characterised by precarious employment,” said Katz, who is a member of the group “Economists of the Left”.
He noted that “a large proportion of informal sector workers earn less than the cost of the basic poverty basket.” In fact, while the minimum monthly wage was drastically increased by the Kirchner administration to 863 pesos (270 dollars), the poverty line set by Indec is 899 pesos a month.
In the formal economy, an estimated 700,000 workers earn the minimum wage, while at least twice that number do so in the informal sector of the economy.
The debate that Kirchner has raised is between a “desarrollista” (economic development-oriented) model and free-market policies along the lines of those implemented by Menem in the 1990s.
Today, the leading advocate of “neoliberal” free-market policies is centre-right businessman Mauricio Macri, the president of the popular Boca football club and a likely presidential candidate in the October elections.
The government argues that if the structural adjustment policies called for by the centre-right to generate a climate of investor confidence had been adopted, Argentina would not have enjoyed the steady recovery seen since late 2002.
Katz, however, said “it is a false dichotomy to say that a neoliberal, monetarist policy would have been worse.”
“That unhealthy policy and the current neo-desarrollista model are not the only possibilities. There is also a model based on the radical redistribution of income that would make it possible to eradicate poverty,” he maintained.
The economic model suggested by Katz would include the use “of the budget surplus to guarantee a universal minimum income for the poor, and adoption of the tax reform that everyone agrees on but which is never carried out, such as a reduction in the value added tax and the incorporation of the capital gains tax.”
With respect to the proposal for a universal minimum income, the interim government of centrist president Eduardo Duhalde (2002-2003) launched the unemployed heads of households plan during the crisis.
The plan, which is still in effect, provides 50 dollars a month in income support – initially to 2.2 million people and to 1.1 million today. In addition, 330,000 single mothers with young children are guaranteed a minimum income under the “families” plan.
These safety net programmes cover almost the entire population in some areas of the country’s poor northern regions.
Today, some 350,000 beneficiaries of the unemployed heads of households plan are counted as employed in the official statistics.
Fausto Spotorno, an economist with the centre-right Orlando Ferreres polling firm, told IPS that “Universal incomes are only useful in the short-term, because they do not encourage people to be more productive.”
Although he supported the safety-net plans put in place by the Duhalde administration, Spotorno said that “in the long-term, the most important thing is education and guaranteeing investment flows.”
In terms of education, some gains made in Argentina in the 19th century survived the recent crisis, such as the strong primary school and literacy indicators.
That situation, which was highlighted in a report by the UNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning, would seem to make it possible for Argentina to meet other MDGs.
But Spotorno sounds a warning when it comes to drawing investments “in the long-term, something that hasn’t been achieved,” and with regard to the possibility of wages continuing to climb “without the economy losing competitiveness.”
“In the 1990s, when wages were higher, unemployment stood at 15 percent,” he pointed out. But the policy “of maintaining a high real exchange rate (the peso was pegged to the dollar throughout the 1990s) helped generate employment, although it also generated inflation, which hurts the poor.”