Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines | Analysis

TRADE-INFORMATION: WTO Deal Hailed, But it Serves a Select Group

Analysis - Johanna Son

SINGAPORE, Dec 12 1996 (IPS) - A tariff-slashing accord on information technology is being hailed as the plum prize at the World Trade Organisation (WTO) ministerial meeting, but this market-opening measure will bring the biggest benefits only to a select group of industrialised powers and fast-growing economies.

An agreement was announced Thursday among the European Union (EU), the United States, Canada and Japan, to launch an initiative to get WTO members, especially Asian countries, to lift all tariffs on information technology (IT) products by 2000.

But while the information technology initiative has hogged the headlines and overshadowed developing-country concerns in the textile and agriculture sector, it is of prime interest only to some 30 or 40 countries that are major importers, exporters or manufacturer of computer software and semiconductors.

On Thursday, EU trade commissioner Leon Brittan called it “the biggest trade step forward that has happened since the end of the Uruguay Round”.

Earlier, he had said the WTO’s first ministerial meeting would not be a “big success” without a deal on information technology, which would provide the “tools of the trade” of the 21st century.

The EU and the United States had worked feverishly through the week to produce an agreement on information technology, putting it squarely as their No. 1 priority at this week’s inaugural ministerial meeting in Singapore.

“The information technology agreement would be the first concrete demonstration of the WTO’s ability to move forward in concert with the changing world around us,” said U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky on the opening day of the meeting Monday.

Washington had come to Singapore armed with the endorsement of the 18 members of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) for an information technology accord.

But the 30 or so countries the United States and the European Union have been meeting on the accord, account for virtually 100 per cent of global trade in IT, valued at 500 billion dollars a year and projected to reach 800 billion dollars by 2000.

And since Asian countries from South Korea to Malaysia are key producers and users of IT, the EU and Washington have bent over backwards to solicit Asian support — and appear to have got it.

Six individual countries and the 15-member EU block comprise the bulk of imports and exports in information technology — Japan, the United States, Singapore, South Korea, Malaysia and Taiwan. Other major players are Canada, Hong Kong, Mexico, China and Singapore.

Japan was the largest information-technology exporter in 1995, with the United States and the European Union next in line.

Tariff reductions under what is for now called a “conditional agreement” will depend on getting economies representing 90 per cent of world trade on IT products to formally accept it by March 15, 1997. The accord will bind only those countries that accede to it since it is not a multilateral agreement of the entire WTO.

The IT agreement left other developing countries unimpressed. They say they were looking for the WTO meeting to make headway on issues like fairer access for textile and agricultural products into industrialised countries.

Proponents of the accord say freeing up IT trade will bring down costs for consumers worldwide. But critics say opening markets for urgent structural problems like debt, may not mean much for many developing and least-developed countries.

“That is of concern only to some, because only a few Third World countries are involved in information technology,” observed Ernest Maganya of the Johannesburg-based Institute for African Alternatives.

While many countries welcomed the idea of an IT deal, one country — the twin-island Caribbean republic of Trinidad and Tobago — publicly questioned the priorities of the WTO.

Responding to WTO director general Renato Ruggiero’s upbeat speech about the role of information technology in an information- based society, Trinidad’s trade minister Mervyn Assam said there is a whole world far removed from that society.

Calling the freeing up of information technology products the “human dimension of globalisation”, Ruggiero said liberalising telecommunications can help put a telephone in every village and often “make the difference between life and death”.

“While it is no doubt very important to put a phone in every village, many of us represented here today have far greater responsibilities to our villages. We must put a school, put a road, put a health office, sometimes start a cooperative and put a sewing machine, put a notice advising of the use of pesticides so as not to jeopardise market access for exportable goods,” Assam pointed out.

“There remains that obvious disparity in the importance which we attach to a village phone — which we do not manufacture and in which we do not have an export interest — and a plethora of competing demands,” he said on Wednesday.

Added Assam: “It will be useful to see whether the success which will attend discussions on information technology will be duplicated in sectors of importance to the export trade of developing countries; textiles and clothing, agriculture.”

Walden Bello of the Bangkok-based Focus on the Global South said the IT accord, for all the publicity around it, is actually “fairly extraneous to this whole (WTO) thing” that was supposed to review implementation and problems with new world trade rules set at the Uruguay Round of trade talks in 1994.

Proponents are also using Asia’s involvement and economic interest in liberalising trade in information technology products to strengthen the accord, which Singaporean officials called a “stand-alone agreement”. Since it is not a WTO accord though initiated by a group of WTO members, it binds only those who agree to it.

Some Asian developing countries, including Malaysia, earlier said they were not “negotiating” an information-technology tariff deal here and were concerned that the accord leave enough room for flexibility on types of products covered and the schedule and deadline of tariff reductions.

But Indonesia, Thailand and the Philippines supported the deal’s concept, since their IT-related industries should benefit from it. “We can live with it, with some flexibility,” said Tunky Ariwibono, head of Indonesia’s delegation.

And despite its initial rhetoric, Malaysia, which has a thriving semiconductor industry, appeared to tone down its objections: Last year, it was sixth largest exporter and fifth biggest importer of IT products. Kuala Lumpur also has ambitious plans to create a ‘Multimedia Super Corridor’ that will lead to an ‘information technology city’ by 2000.

The IT accord is also conditional on participating economies being satisfied with the plan as it progresses in the next few years. It provides some elbow room for developing countries to pace tariff reduction on certain information technology products, though an EU spokesman said “the degree of flexibility needed is a rather small percentage”.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags