Sunday, November 22, 2026
Antoaneta Bezlova
- In pursuit of a perceived modern identity, the ancient capital of China is dismantling pieces of its cultural heritage, leaving the usual trail of nostalgia among city dwellers and foreign admirers.
The razing of a historical courtyard and the fencing of the Ming dynasty tombs in old Beijing have again sparked the classic controversy between “progress” and the need to preserve cultural identity.
A highway will soon pass through a graceful courtyard in southwest Beijing where, ironically, the late imperial China launched in the late 19th century its drive for modernisation known as The 100 Days of Reform.
This is also where Sun Yat-sen, the revered father of the Chinese republic, lectured his followers.
Simultaneously, the 500 year-old Ming dynasty tombs, in the ancient capital near Beijing and still resisting the modernity drive, have recently been slated for protection and development.
“It is sad to watch all this,” observes Zhu Weimin, one of China’s leading artists and a long-time Beijing resident.
“It seems like we can’t halt a process of destruction which began with (former communist president and founder of the People’s Republic) Mao Zedong’s decision to demolish the city walls and get rid of Beijing’s image as a city of antiquity,” he says.
Old city dwellers who remember Beijing in the years before the communists came to power in 1949, feel heartbroken at the sight of swiftly vanishing “hutong” (narrow alleys) and “siheyuan” (courtyards).
Says Shu Yi, a campaigner to save old Beijing and son of the famous Chinese writer Lao She: “The ancient Beijing was composed of two parts. One is the Forbidden City and the numerous Imperial gardens and parks; another one is the residential area for city dwellers, encompassing hundreds of hutongs and siheyuan, which gave old Beijing its most distinctive feature.”
“You cannot have only the Imperial part of the city and destroy the other one,” argues Shu Yi.
“It will not be Beijing then. But these days most of the narrow lanes and courtyards have disappeared. Can you still trace back the culture of the city from 3,000 or even 1,000 years ago?,” he adds.
The story of the courtyard where the reformist movement of late 19th century was launched, is a case in point. Here, one hundred years ago, enlightened scholars Kang Youwei and Liang Qichao led 200 countrymen in a drive to modernise the backward and decaying Qing Empire.
The movement lasted only 100 days before the Dowager Empress Cixi struck back and punished the reformers.
The house was declared a historic monument by Beijing’s Cultural Relics Bureau, but this didn’t help it escape the demolition as the city masters decided that a road was more important.
The bureau has promised to rebuild the courtyard elsewhere, but many feel the substitute will be a pale replica with no significance whatsoever.
Many in Beijing have doubts about the success of other restoration projects completed in the capital and its vicinity, where winds of commerce and profit seem to replace the spirit of the old China ostensibly being preserved.
Long-term foreign residents in the capital point out that with current plans to restore the ruined Ming tombs, the government is actually ruining the last place where one could get a sense of an unchanging China.
Only two of the 13 tombs have been restored and converted into museums and popular tourist attractions. The rest have been left to sleep into oblivion and preserve its romantic flavour of fixed antiquity.
The two that have been restored may well anticipate what will happen to the entire site, featuring colorful steel fences and loud Karaoke sound systems.
The site has long been a weekend retreat of peace for expatriates, more concerned with Beijing’s noise and crowds than the princesses’ and emperors’, whose spirits the locals have so far being mindful not to offend by picnicking in their resting premises.
The custodians of the cultural relics claimed the deserted tombs need better environmental protection and from now on, anyone wishing to savour their unique charm should apply for permission to enter and pay for it.
The decision put in motion squads of workers who began installing new steel fences in front of Kangling and Deling tombs, and store bricks to repair their crumbling crimson walls.
With the start of this work came the realisation by many that this was the end of the magical journey in the past undertaken in the Valley of the Thirteen Tombs, built by the Ming emperors five centuries ago.
“I want to make it clear that we are not closing off the tombs,” rebuts Hao, a spokesman for the Changping county. “We mean to protect them. People can still come here for a picnic but of course, they shall pay for it.”