Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

DEVELOPMENT-PALESTINE: Economy a Casualty of Conflict

IPS Correspondents

DUBAI, Sep 20 2003 (IPS) - That conflict is bad for the economy is known to many, but new International Monetary Fund (IMF) figures showing that it has shrunk the Palestinian economy’s Gross Domestic Product by 30 percent drives home just how much debilitating it can be.

But figures released here Saturday, ahead of the annual meetings of the World Bank and IMF next week, also show the resilience of the economy although everyday life has been affected by the second Palestinian ‘intifadah’ or resistance, Israel’s economic restrictions and the Palestinian Authority’s own problems.

”Tourism stopped to a standstill. Palestinian workers could not work in Israel any more,” Karim Nashashibi, the IMF’s resident representative in West Bank-Gaza, said Saturday in describing the changes in Palestine over the years.

”There were checkpoints, and curfews, and roadblocks in various areas in the West Bank which basically fragmented the whole West Bank and, you know, paralysed economic activity and paralysed trade,” he said.

His analysis was echoed by a new IMF report, ‘Economic Performance and Reform Under Conflict Conditions’. ”Before the intifadah between 1994 and 1999, the economy grew at a remarkable rate and was able to generate jobs and increase standards of living for its rapidly growing population,” it said.

”With the onset of the intifadah, the Palestinian economy went into a serious decline,” it added.

Real GDP growth declined from 8.9 percent in 1999 to negative 5.4 percent in 2000 and further to an estimated negative 14.5 percent in 2002, according to the report.

The unemployment rate in the Palestinian areas, where 57 percent of the population is below 20 years old, fell in the mid-nineties but has sharply risen since the ‘intifadah’ in 1999. From 11.8 percent in 1999, it grew to 25.5 percent in 1991 and to some 31.3 percent in 2002.

But Adam Bennett, IMF chief of mission for West Bank-Gaza, said that despite the difficulties, ”the economy has been much more resilient than one might have expected” and that the decline in the Gross Domestic Product was in the area of 30 percent over the past three years instead of the 50 percent often spoken about. Nominal GDP has fallen from 4.44 billion dollars to an estimated 2.97 billion dollars in 2002.

”In fact, by looking at data for the first half of this year, there are signs it is even beginning to recover somewhat,” he said.

Still, this is far from certain amid the violence, the suicide attacks by Palestinians, Israel’s tough retaliatory measures and threats to expel Palestinian Authority leader Yasser Arafat.

There are also other factors, such as the construction of a wall starting in 2002 to separate Palestinian areas, which mean even more economic consequences for an economy so heavily dependent on access to Jerusalem. Already, the movement of Palestinians and goods into Israeli territory is restricted.

”In addition to the political repercussions, and the issue of accessibility to markets and services, this wall goes through Palestinian villages and envelopes Jerusalem, cutting off the hub for economic activity to Palestinians,” said Nigel Roberts, country director for the West Bank and Gaza department of the IMF, said in an interview with IPS.

In September 2000, an estimated 128,000 Palestinians worked in Israel and the Israeli settlements. But with ever since the outbreak of the ‘intifadah’ and fears of suicide attacks, the Israeli government has cut back on the issuance of work permits.

The Palestinian economy has also made its way through signs of economic trouble, such as 10 to 15 declines in banking deposits, which are now picking up, and falling fuel and cement consumption that indicate a weak economy.

Likewise, the finances of the Palestinian Authority were hurt after Israel, reacting to the ‘intifadah’, withheld the clearance revenues they collected on behalf of the Palestinians. This, however, was no longer the case as of end-2002.

Roberts said the fact that the Palestinians economy has shown resilience is also due to the current economic leadership of the Palestinian Authority, which he called ”the best in 10 years”.

”There is a higher degree of involvement now unlike earlier when donors would get frustrated,” he said. The Palestinian Authority received 460 million dollars in aid in 2002.

According to a World Bank report on the Palestinian economic crisis, the Palestinian Authority employs 26 percent of those still working inside the West Bank and Gaza and pays 40 percent of all domestic wages. IMF officials also praised the ”reforms” being undertaken by the Palestinian authority, in areas such as the budgetary process and pointed to the fact that a stock exchange continues to operate in Nablus in the West Bank.

The IMF report said a mix of laws is also being prepared – in the areas of company law, intellectual property rights, securities ” – that ”should make the Palestinian economy one of the most modern and market-oriented economies in the region”.

But talk of such reforms seemed quite distant from the everyday realities of Palestinians, at a time when the future is uncertain given the Israeli government’s crackdown on the Palestinians, the ineffectivity of the ‘road map’ to peace brokered by Washington, and continued violence.

At Saturday’s briefing, an Arabic-speaking journalist said that the ”very nice image” of the Palestinian economy painted by the IMF does not fit with the fact that ”none of the services are of a basic standard or acceptable standard in terms of health, education, general circumstances of living”.

The journalist asked Fund officials: ”How can you as the IMF push forward development at this daily level of the citizens and not at the level of stock exchange in Nablus or another achievement in the economy in general?

Meantime, Roberts said in an interview he did not think the post-conflict needs of Iraq would divert funds away from the Palestinian people. He said that a minimum of one billion dollars is required every year to maintain the Palestinian Authority.

However, he acknowledged that political instability makes it difficult to focus on sustainable economic development and maintain medium-term development programmes because they are really dependent on political circumstances.

”One of the reasons the Palestinian cause will not be hurt is because everyone realises how important and sensitive an issue it is,” explained Marwan Nemr, an analyst with ‘Al-Iktissad Wal-Aamal’, an Arab business magazine. ”Despite the political turmoil and worsening situation, it is very important to focus on economic development – however minimal.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags